Drug-Related Deaths in China: An Analysis of a Spontaneous Reporting System

Background: Adverse drug reactions with an outcome of death represent the most serious consequences and are inherently important for pharmacovigilance. The nature and characteristics of drug-related deaths are to a large extent unknown in the Chinese population. This study aims to characterize drug-related deaths by analysis of individual case safety reports (ICSRs) with an outcome of death in China.

Methods: The characteristics of death ICSRs were analyzed by descriptive statistics of a large multi-provincial pharmacovigilance database in China.

Results: There were 1,731 ICSRs with an outcome of death, representing 0.95% of all serious cases and 0.05% of all reported ICSRs. Most death ICSRs (78.57%) were reported by medical institutions. Only 16.00% of death ICSRs were reported by manufacturers or distributors. The reporting rate of death ICSRs in the age group of 0–4 years was significantly higher than patients aged 5–64 years. Patients aged over 64 years had the highest reporting rate of death ICSRs. Male patients generally had a higher reporting rate of death ICSRs than female patients. However, the reporting rate of female patients exceeded that of male patients in the age group of 20–34 years. Among 3,861 drugs implicated, ceftriaxone sodium with 146 (3.78%) records of death ranked first. Dexamethasone with 131 (3.39%) records of death ranked second. Qingkailing, an injectable traditional Chinese medicine with 75 (1.94%) records of death, ranked the fifth most frequently implicated medicine.

Conclusion: Young children and elderly patients have a higher risk of drug-related deaths than patients aged 5–64 years. Female patients generally have a lower risk of drug-related deaths than male patients. However, female patients of reproductive age (aged 20–34 years) have a higher risk of drug-related deaths than male patients, hinting that physiological changes and drug uses for child bearing, giving birth, or birth control may significantly increase the risk of death for female patients aged 20–34 years. This paper suggests more research on the safe use of drugs for young children, elderly patients, and female patients of reproductive ages. Pharmacovigilance databases can be valuable resources for comprehensive understanding of drug-related problems.

Introduction

Drugs are safe and effective therapies for numerous diseases and circumstances. The incidence of severe adverse effects is generally low in clinical use. However, once it happens, it may seriously threaten the health of patients and even lead to deaths (Moore et al., 2007; Lombardi et al., 2020). Adverse drug reactions (ADRs) have long been a major public health problem and a significant cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide (Lazarou et al., 1998; Pardo Cabello et al., 2016; Montané, et al., 2018; Pardo-Cabello et al., 2018; Patel and Patel, 2018; Montané and Castells, 2021). ADRs with an outcome of death represent the most serious consequences and are inherently important for pharmacovigilance (Marwitz et al., 2020). Although there have been studies assessing the incidence of drug-related deaths, information on the issue is rather limited, which left many questions unsolved (Montané et al., 2018).

Individual case safety reports (ICSRs) are an important information source for the study of ADRs (Klepper and Edwards, 2011; Streefland, 2018). Although spontaneous reporting data cannot give exact estimates of the magnitude of drug-related mortality, it can highlight large dimensions and some characteristics of the issue. There have been some studies on drug-related mortality by analysis of databases of spontaneous reporting in some countries (Wester et al., 2007; Leone et al., 2008; Marwitz et al., 2020). However, the nature and characteristics of drug-related deaths is to a large extent unknown in many developing countries including China.

Spontaneous reporting has the advantage of covering a large number of patients, a wide range of drugs, and being relatively cost-effective for the study of drug safety (Leone et al., 2008). With the development of a pharmacovigilance system in China, ICSRs with an outcome of death received each year have accumulated to a large volume and necessitate studies for better understanding of the sources and content. The objective of this study is to characterize ICSRs with an outcome of death by analysis of data sources of a large multi-provincial pharmacovigilance platform in China.

Materials and Methods

Data Source

The Chinese pharmacovigilance system is based on a network of 34 regional centers, including 23 provincial, 2 special administrative regional, 4 municipal, and 5 autonomous regional pharmacovigilance centers. Like many countries, ADR declaration is mandatory for hospitals, pharmaceutical manufacturers, and distributors but voluntary for patients in China. Adverse drug events (ADEs) reported spontaneously or derived from active pharmacovigilance projects or observational studies were evaluated by trained pharmacologists of regional pharmacovigilance centers and became complete ICSRs before entering pharmacovigilance databases. Data used in this study were retrieved from the Pan-pearl Delta ADR Monitoring Platform (Pan-pearl Platform), a multi-regional service of 12 member provincial pharmacovigilance centers in southern and central China to support postmarketing surveillance of medicinal products and promote cooperation between the regulatory authorities of 12 member provinces. Anonymized ICSRs from 12 member provincial pharmacovigilance centers were forwarded to the Pan-pearl Platform using a standardized format containing structured information. Each member provincial center was responsible for the management and quality control of the data.

Data stored in the platform consist of a modified national version of the World Health Organization Adverse Reaction Terminology (WHO-ART). This categorization is hierarchical and includes medical terms clustered into body system organ classes. Drugs are coded according to the WHO Collaborating Center for Drug Statistics Methodology International Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical (ATC) classification. The detailed description of the information resources of the Pan-pearl Platform is described elsewhere (Li et al., 2020). As of May 7, 2018, there were 3,429,002 ICSRs, including 182,417 serious ICSRs, available in the Pan-pearl Platform.

Concerning the data scale of the platform, there were 2,756,437 ICSRs in the Pan-pearl Platform from 2009 to 2017, accounting for 26.80% of all ICSRs reported to the spontaneous reporting system (SRS) of China during the same period (Li et al., 2018).

Selection of Cases

There were 2,398 ICSRs with an outcome of death retrieved from the platform between January 1, 2002, and May 7, 2018, and 6,239 drug-ADE records obtained by splitting the 2,398 ICSRs off. The number of drug ADE records exceeded ICSRs because each ICSR may include more than one ADE and/or drug.

The causality between death and related drug(s) for each ICSR was assessed by the staff of a member provincial pharmacovigilance center based on the World Health Organization (WHO) standardized case–causality assessment criteria. ICSRs with causality assessments of unlikely, conditional/unclassified, or no documented causality assessments were excluded. There were 1,757 ICSRs with causality assessments of being certain (N = 48), probable (N = 376), or possible (N = 1,333).

Two ICSRs with missed drug names and categories and 24 ICSRs related to vaccines were excluded. As most ICSRs of vaccines were generally handled by the National Disease Control and Prevention (NCDC), only a small proportion of ICSRs related to vaccines were reported to the Pan-pearl Platform. This study excluded ICSRs related to vaccines and left the issue to other studies designed for the safety of vaccines by putting the data from spontaneous reporting and the NCDC together. There were 1,731 ICSRs finally included for analysis. The case selection process and exclusion/inclusion criteria are summarized in Figure 1.

FIGURE 1

FIGURE 1. Flow chart of study design and case selection.

For the convenience of data processing and analysis, biologically inactive solutions used as solvents of other bioactive substances were excluded with the assumption that biologically inactive solutions (such as bi-distilled water or water solution containing glucose and/or sodium chloride) used as solvents of bioactive substances had made no contribution to the deaths of patients being treated. The number of ICSRs remained the same (1,731 ICSRs) after the exclusion of solvents.

Data Analysis

Descriptive statistics were conducted to analyze the characteristics of death ICSRs, including annual numbers of ICSRs being forwarded to the platform and the proportion of ICSRs with an outcome of death in the platform, the geographical and time distribution, types of reporting sources, age and gender distribution, major ADEs related to death ICSRs and drugs or drug combinations implicated, dosage forms or routes of administration, frequently reported primary diseases, and so on. Due to the observational nature of the data and the expected existence of differences between groups, we did not perform statistical testing and only performed a comparative description.

Results

General Descriptions of Individual Case Safety Reports With an Outcome of Death

Among 3,429,002 ICSRs available in the Pan-pearl Platform between January 1, 2002, and May 7, 2018, there were 1,731 ICSRs with an outcome of death, representing 0.95% of all serious cases and 0.05% of all reported ICSRs. The annual number of death ICSRs exceeded 100 in 11 of the recorded 17 years from 2002 to 2018. Guangdong, Hunan, Yunnan, Guangxi, and Sichuan ranked top five provinces with highest numbers of death ICSRs among the 12 member provinces of the Pan-pearl region. The geographical and time distribution of death ICSRs in the platform is given in Supplementary Table S1.

The annual numbers of ICSRs being forwarded to the Pan-pearl Platform and the percentages of death ICSRs in the context of all ICSRs received annually are displayed in Figure 2.

FIGURE 2

FIGURE 2. The annual numbers of ICSRs reported and the percentages of death ICSRs in Pan-pearl Platform.

With the development of the SRS in China, the annual numbers of ICSRs and ICSRs with an outcome of death were both on the rise and reached the peak in 2014. As a lot of provinces stopped uploading data to the platform, the annual numbers of ICSRs and ICSRs with an outcome of death started to decline after 2014. The platform officially ceased operation in 2019.

However, five provinces, including Fujian, Guangdong, Guanxi, Guizhou, and Hunan, continued to upload data throughout the whole period from 2002 to 2018. The total number of ICSRs reported of the five provinces was 2,029,916, accounting for 59.20% of the total number in the platform. The annual numbers of ICSRs reported and the percentages of death ICSRs in five provinces with all data available during the whole period are given in Supplementary Figure S1. The results are similar to the whole dataset of the platform.

Statistics on reporting sources of death ICSRs, including professions of the reporters and types of the reporting bodies, are given in Table 1. It can be seen that more than half of the death ICSRs were reported by physicians, followed by consumers (20.17%) and pharmacists (17.56%). Only 7.51% of the ICSRs were reported by nurses. As to the reporting bodies, medical institutions reported most death ICSRs (78.57%). Only 16.00% of death ICSRs were reported by manufacturers or distributors.

TABLE 1

TABLE 1. Number of death ICSRs for different types of reporting sources.

Age and Gender Distribution of Individual Case Safety Reports With an Outcome of Death

As ages were missing in seven ICSRs, the total number of ICSRs included in the analysis of age distribution is 1,724 (Figure 3). As can be seen in Figure 3, the age group of 0–4 years has the highest number of death ICSRs, accounting for 11.19% of all reported death ICSRs. The number of death ICSRs decreased with age and reached the lowest point at the age of 10–14 years. The numbers of death ICSRs increased with age for patients aged over 14 years and began to decline in patients aged over 65 years. Since there were significant differences in the sizes of the population between different age groups and the number of death ICSRs may be influenced accordingly, this study standardized the age–gender distribution of death ICSRs by per million inhabitants to strip out the impact of population sizes between different age groups. As there were 12 ICSRs with missing age or gender, the total number of ICSRs included in the analysis of age–gender distribution is 1,719 (Figure 4 and Figure 5).

FIGURE 3

FIGURE 3. The numbers and percentages of reported death ICSRs for different age groups.

FIGURE 4

FIGURE 4. Age-gender distribution of death ICSRs by per million inhabitants.

FIGURE 5

FIGURE 5. Age-gender distribution for all-cause deaths and drug-related deaths.

Since all-cause mortality may influence the age–gender distribution of death ICSRs, we calculated all-cause deaths and drug-related deaths of both sexes for different age groups (Figure 5). Data of all-cause mortality come from annual census figures of the National Bureau of Statistics of China (NBS) (National Bureau of Statistics of China, 2010).

Comparing the age–gender distribution of all-cause deaths and drug-related deaths, there were 4.50 drug-related deaths per million inhabitants for the age group 0–4 years, accounting for 11.23% of the total deaths of all age groups. The number of all-cause deaths per million inhabitants in the age group 0–4 years was 1,418.80, accounting for 1.63% of the total deaths of all age groups.

From Figures 4 and 5, it can be seen that female patients generally have a lower number of death ICSRs than male patients for almost all age groups except for the age group of 20–34 years. For better understanding the reason why the number of death ICSRs of female patients exceeded male patients at the age group of 20–34 years, this study extracted detailed information on death ICSRs related to drug use of female reproductive disorders from the dataset and presented these in Supplementary Table S2.

ADEs Frequently Related to Death Individual Case Safety Reports and Drugs Implicated

This study explored ADEs frequently implicated in death ICSRs and suspected drugs related to the specific ADEs (Supplementary Table S3). Anaphylactic shock is the most common ADE implicated in death ICSRs.

There were 3,861 drugs implicated in 1,731 ICSRs with an outcome of death. Among 1,731 ICSRs, there were 827 (47.78%) ICSRs with one drug suspected, 397 (22.93%) ICSRs with two drugs suspected, 214 (12.36%) with three, and 144 (8.32%) with four (Figure 6).

FIGURE 6

FIGURE 6. The number of suspected drugs implicated and the corresponding number of death ICSRs.

This study also analyzed drugs frequently implicated in death ICSRs and the corresponding high-frequency ADEs related to the specific drug (Table 2). Among 3,861 drugs implicated, anti-infectious agents were drugs most frequently implicated, including 146 (3.78%) cases of ceftriaxone sodium, 100 (2.59%) cases of ribavirin, 99 (2.56%) cases of cefoperazone sodium and sulbactam sodium, 58 (1.50%) cases of cefotaxime sodium, 56 (1.45%) cases of clindamycin, 53 (1.37%) cases of benzylpenicillin, and 52 (1.35%) cases of potassium sodium dehydroandrograpolide succinate. Dexamethasone with 131 (3.39%) cases of death ICSRs ranked second. Qingkailing, an injectable traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), with 75 (1.94%) cases of death ICSRs ranked the fifth most frequently implicated medicine.

TABLE 2

TABLE 2. Drugs frequently implicated and the corresponding high-frequency ADEs.

Suspected drug combinations frequently implicated in death ICSRs and corresponding high-frequency ADEs related to the specific drug combination are given in Table 3.

TABLE 3

TABLE 3. Suspected drug combinations frequently implicated and corresponding high-frequency ADEs.

This study explored the number of drugs suspected and the corresponding number of drug death records for conventional medicines and TCMs (Table 4). Among the 3,861 drugs implicated in death ICSRs, there were 3,357 conventional medicines and 504 TCMs. TCMs accounted for 13.05% of the total number of drugs implicated.

TABLE 4

TABLE 4. Drug death records for conventional medicines and TCMs.

Dosage Forms, Routes of Administration, and Primary Diseases Reported

Major dosage forms implicated in death ICSRs for conventional medicine and TCM are given in Table 5. For conventional medicines, there were 2,877 (85.70%) drugs in the dosage form of injections, while the number (percentage) of injections for TCMs is 388 (76.98%). Injections were the dosage form ranked first in death ICSRs for both conventional medicines and TCMs. Traditional Chinese herbal decoction pieces, as the main forms of TCM products, ranked second followed by injections.

TABLE 5

TABLE 5. Dosage forms implicated in death ICSRs.

In order to explore the impact of routes of administration to the outcome of death, we calculated the number of cases of different routes of administration in death ICSRs (Table 6). As can be seen from Table 6 there are some similarities between conventional medicines and TCMs. Among all routes of administration, intravenous injections ranked first, followed by oral dosage forms and intramuscular injections. As there were injections other than intravenous injections, such as intramuscular injection, peritoneal injection, subcutaneous injection, intradermal injection, and so on, the number of death ICSRs for all injections accounted for more than 80% of ICSRs of all dosage forms, reflecting that physicians in China are prone to prescribe drugs parenterally.

TABLE 6

TABLE 6. Routes of administration implicated in death ICSRs.

This study analyzed frequently reported primary diseases implicated in death ICSRs (Table 7). In the dataset, primary diseases refer to illnesses that need to be diagnosed or treated. They are usually equivalent to therapeutic indications (reasons for use) of the suspected drugs but not always the case. For example, iohexol may be used for radiological examination (reason for use) for a patient with pulmonary malignancy as primary disease. Acute upper respiratory tract infections ranked the first primary disease, followed by chronic renal failure (N18), influenza, virus not identified (J11), acute bronchitis (J20), and so on. Eight of the top 10 primary diseases in death ICSRs can be classified as infectious diseases, reflecting the high incidence of infectious diseases in the Chinese population and the high frequency of drug use and deaths.

TABLE 7

TABLE 7. Most frequently reported primary diseases (top 10).

Discussion

Reporting Sources of Death Individual Case Safety Reports

This study provided information on the characteristics of drug-related deaths in China between 2002 and 2018. Statistics showed that physicians ranked first in the reporting of death ICSRs (53.55%), and pharmacists ranked second (17.56%). The role and knowledge structure of pharmacists are advantageous for reporting ADRs (Barnes and Butler, 2020). As to the reporting bodies, 78.57% of death ICSRs were reported by medical institutions. Only 16.0% of death ICSRs were reported by manufacturers or distributors. This is very different from similar studies in the US demonstrating that most ICSRs (96.20%) came from manufacturers (Marwitz et al., 2020). China's SRS system lacks active participation of drug manufacturers and distributors. The awareness and reporting capacity of manufacturers and distributors need to be improved.

Percentage of Death Individual Case Safety Reports in the Context of Individual Case Safety Reports Reported in the SRS System

With the development of the SRS in China, the annual numbers of ICSRs and ICSRs with an outcome of death were both on the rise. It is noteworthy that there was an exceptionally high proportion of death ICSRs between 2003 and 2006, and the percentages of annual death ICSRs showed a downward trend during the early years of China's SRS system from 2002 to 2010. This can be explained by the characteristics of the initial stage of the SRS of China. More attention was paid to reports of serious cases and deaths at the initial stage, and the total number of annual reports was small. After 2010 the percentages of death ICSRs went up and down in a narrow range, reflecting that the number of death ICSRs increased proportionally with the total number of ICSRs reported except in the year 2018 in which only a small number of total ICSRs and death ICSRs were uploaded to the platform.

There is also another influencing factor added to this trend. The supervisory authorities have been pushing hard on medical institutions, pharmaceutical manufacturers, and distributors to report more ICSRs, resulting in more reports of minor ADEs or external symptoms of related physical conditions reported and extra decrease in the proportion of serious or death ICSRs after 2010 (Li et al., 2019).

Death ICSRs in the present study represented 0.05% of all reported ICSRs, much less than previous similar studies in other countries, such as approximately 1.00% in Canada (Gowdey and Brennan, 1985), 2.40% and 3.10% in Sweden (Böttiger et al., 1979; Wester et al., 2007), 1.66% in Italy (Leone et al., 2008), and 6.30% and 9.60% in the US (Chyka, 2000; Marwitz et al., 2020). The gap in the proportion of death ICSRs between China and other countries provides a new clue for reconsidering the policies governing ADE reporting.

Characteristics of Age and Gender Distribution of Death Individual Case Safety Reports

The nonstandardized age and gender distribution of ICSRs with an outcome of death may not accurately reflect the true nature of death ICSRs because of the significant differences in the sizes of population between different age groups. This study standardized the age–gender distribution of death ICSRs by calculations of the number of death ICSRs per million inhabitants to strip out the impact of population sizes. The number of death ICSRs per million inhabitants in the age group of 0–4 years was significantly higher than patients aged 5–64 years. The lowest point was at the age group of 5–20 years, and then the number increased continuously with age. Patients aged over 64 years have the highest number of death ICSRs per million inhabitants.

A number of reasons may contribute to the exceptionally high reporting number of death ICSRs per million children aged 0–4 years. For very young children, the variable weight and body surface area, and immaturity of the organ system, may affect their ability to metabolize and excrete medications (Venkatesh, 2010). Research has established marked differences between children and adults in drug pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics (Zimmerman et al., 2019). Many medicines prescribed to children have not been studied in this patient population or formally approved for pediatric use (Roberts et al., 2003; Hwang et al., 2019; Zimmerman et al., 2019). Besides, a lot of medications lack standardized dosing regimens for young children (Rauch et al., 2018; Powell et al., 2021) and make the appropriate use of drugs for very young children difficult and cause more adverse events to occur. The immaturity of the organ system of very young children may cause more serious events or deaths.

Comparing the age–gender distribution between drug-related deaths and all-cause deaths, the percentage of drug-related deaths for the age group of 0–4 years relative to all age groups is significantly higher than that of all-cause deaths, hinting that children aged 0–4 years are more vulnerable to drug-related deaths. The safety use of medicine in young children calls for more attention and scientific research.

The high rate of drug-related deaths for patients aged over 64 years is expected and in agreement with other studies on drug-related mortality (Chyka, 2000; Wester et al., 2007; Hartholt et al., 2010; Ruiter et al., 2012). It has been reported that the percentage of hospitalizations attributed to drug therapy is highest for elderly people (Beijer and de Blaey, 2002; Pirmohamed et al., 2004; van der Hooft et al., 2006; Salvi et al., 2012; Linkens et al., 2020). The reason can be explained by a series of age-related changes in pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics. The body function deteriorates with age for elderly people; the frequency and severity of underlying diseases and frequency of drug uses or combined drug uses (polypharmacy and risk of drug-drug interactions) are likely to increase with age (Letinier et al., 2019; Kardas et al., 2021). All these may contribute to the high reporting frequencies of total ICSRs and death ICSRs in elderly people.

In terms of gender, the number of death ICSRs for male patients was generally higher than for female patients (58.52 vs. 41.31%), hinting that male patients generally have a higher risk of death ICSRs than female patients. The results are in agreement with the fact that men have higher all-cause mortality than women in general and in every age group.

Female patients usually take more drugs (Ferrajolo et al., 2019) and tend to experience more ADEs than male patients do (Wester et al., 2007; de Vries et al., 2019). However, the number of death ICSRs of female patients was generally lower than male patients. The contradiction has been studied, and the results are generally in agreement with similar studies (Chyka, 2000; Zoppi et al., 2000; Buajordet et al., 2001; Juntti-Patinen and Neuvonen, 2002).

Opposite to the general rule, the age group of 20–34 years is the only age group in which the number of death ICSRs of female patients outnumbered male patients. This may be explained by the fact that female patients aged 20–34 years may experience physiological changes and drug uses for child bearing, giving birth, or birth control and also possibly higher susceptibility to drug-related injuries than male patients at this age. More studies are needed for a better understanding of the safety of medicinal products for female patients aged 20–34 years.

Drugs, Dosage Forms and ADEs Implicated in Death Individual Case Safety Reports

This study demonstrated that there were a variety of drugs associated with death ICSRs, indicating that drugs of various pharmacological groups may cause fatalities. Anti-infectious agents, including ceftriaxone sodium, ribavirin, cefoperazone sodium and sulbactam sodium, cefotaxime sodium, clindamycin, benzylpenicillin, and potassium sodium dehydroandrograpolide succinate, ranked top 10. Injections were the most frequent dosage form, and anaphylactic shock was the most frequently reported ADE. The results were similar to an Italian study (Leone et al., 2008). Anaphylactic shock is a known serious ADE to a series of anti-infectious agents, and the frequency depends on both the population exposed and the dosage forms or routes of administration (Baldo et al., 2001). Like what happened in Italy (Vaccheri et al., 2000; Leone et al., 2008) widespread administering of anti-infectious agents parenterally is also a serious problem in China (Long and Li, 2010; Zhang, 2010). Dexamethasone with 131 (3.39%) cases of death ICSRs ranked second.

There are some differences between our study and some other similar studies. There were studies reporting that blood and bone marrow dysfunction and hemorrhages were the most frequently reported ADEs (Wester et al., 2007; Leone et al., 2008). Anticoagulants were most frequently involved in spontaneous fatal reports in a German study (Tiaden et al., 2005) and a Swedish study (Wester et al., 2007). Anticoagulants were among the most frequently implicated drug classes in some Nordic studies investigating fatal ADRs in hospital settings (Zoppi et al., 2000; Ebbesen et al., 2001). Antineoplastic and immunosuppressive agents were the drugs most frequently suspected in spontaneously reported deaths in a US study (Chyka, 2000). Nervous system agents were the most frequently reported medications associated with death ICSRs, followed by anti-infective agents for systemic use, musculoskeletal and cardiovascular system agents, and musculoskeletal agents in two Canadian studies (Mittmann et al., 1997; Liu et al., 2001). It is difficult to explain these differences, but they may be due to differences in drug utilization patterns or different attitudes of the patients and health professionals towards ADR reporting. It is necessary to further explore the correlation between drug utilization patterns and health results.

Concerning drug combinations suspected, dexamethasones combined with various anti-infectious agents, including cefoperazone sodium and sulbactam sodium injection, ceftriaxone sodium injection, lincomycin hydrochloride injection, ceftriaxone sodium injection, and Qingkailing injection, were the most frequently implicated drug combinations in death ICSRs. The results indicate the possibility of misuse or overuse of the combination of glucocorticoids and anti-infectious agents in China which require for more attention and research.

It is noteworthy that Qingkailing, an injectable TCM which has been reported in widespread use in China (Li et al., 2018), ranked the fifth most frequently implicated medicine in death ICSRs. Qingkailing combined with dexamethasone sodium phosphate injection and ceftriaxone sodium injection ranked the fourth most frequently implicated drug combination. In China's SRS system, Qingkailing is among the most frequently reported TCM products, and a warning of severe adverse effects has been issued by the Food and Drug Administration of China (CFDA) (Li et al., 2015; Li et al., 2018), the predecessor of the National Medical Products Administration (NMPA).

TCMs accounted for 13.05% of the total number of drugs implicated in death ICSRs, reflecting the widespread use and prevalence of serious adverse effects of TCM products.

It is generally believed by many people in China that TCMs, being natural or derived from natural products, are safe remedies with no harmful effects. Statistics in this study showed that the risk of adverse effects of TCM products cannot be ignored. The risk of adverse effects of TCM injections, like conventional injections, is much higher than any other dosage forms (Li et al., 2019). The safety surveillance of TCM injections calls for more attention and research (Li et al., 2019).

Infectious diseases were the most frequently reported primary diseases implicated in death ICSRs, reflecting the high incidence of the diseases and drug use for anti-infectious purpose and the large scale of mortality related to anti-infectious medicines. In addition to infectious diseases, chronic renal failure and other forms of acute ischemic heart disease were also frequently related to death ICSRs.

Limitation

We should bear in mind several important limitations. Firstly, this study is based on spontaneously reported ICSRs, which mainly reflect the concerns of healthcare professionals rather than the actual number of deaths. Other shortcomings related to spontaneous reporting may also affect the reliability of the study, such as the quality of the information, selective reporting, and under-reporting (Guo et al., 2021).

Secondly, the correlation between death and drug use was based on the judgments of the reporters and specialists of provincial pharmacovigilance centers of the Pan-pearl region. As a significant proportion of patients whose deaths were attributed to a drug were terminally ill, it would be a complicated task to identify the drugs as the cause of death, especially in patients with polypharmacy and comorbidity. There were always plenty of other possible explanations which cannot be ruled out. Moreover, in fatal cases with a long period of disease, it is more likely that clinicians attribute deaths to underlying diseases than to the therapies provided.

Thirdly, the limitation on the scope of the data source cannot be ignored. The dataset being used in the study were retrieved from a pharmacovigilance platform with 12 member provincial centers in southern or central China, accounting for 26.80% of all ICSRs reported to the SRS of China. This study mainly reflects the scales and features of drug-related deaths in southern and central China. Generalization of the results to the whole Chinese population should be done with caution.

Last but not the least, this study ignored the effect of inactive solutions used as solvents of bioactive substances that might affect the validity of the results to some degree as biologically inactive solutions might have some effect themselves or influence the effects of the drugs being solved and therefore influence the outcome of the patient.

Conclusion

Children aged 0–4 years and patients aged over 64 years were at higher risk of drug-related deaths than patients aged 5–64 years. The reporting rates of drug-related deaths of female patients were generally lower than male patients except for the age group of 20–34 years, hinting that the physiological changes and drug uses for child bearing, giving birth, or birth control may significantly increase the risk of death for female patients aged 20–34 years. Anti-infectious agents were the drugs most frequently implicated in drug-related deaths. Dexamethasone ranked second. The dosage form of injections, primary diseases of infectious diseases, and ADE of anaphylactic shock were most frequently implicated in drug-related deaths. TCMs accounted for 13.05% of the total number of drugs implicated. The safety use of drugs for very young children, elderly patients, and female patients of reproductive ages calls for more attention and research. Pharmacovigilance databases can be valuable resources for comprehensive understanding of drug-related problems.

Data Availability Statement

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary Material; further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.

Author Contributions

HL planned and performed the study and drafted the manuscript. JD and PY helped in concept design, data analysis, and interpretation. XR participated in study design, medical interpretation of the results, and revision of the manuscript. All authors contributed to the preparation of the final version of this manuscript.

Funding

This research was supported by the Henan Provincial Key Scientific Research Project of Colleges and Universities (No. 22A330002), the Henan Provincial Research Project on Medical Education (Wjlx2021043), the Postgraduate Education Reform and Quality Improvement Project of Henan Province (YJS2022AL100), the Project of Science and Technology of Kaifeng City (No. 2103006), the Project of Henan University (No. HDXJJG2020-20), and the Henan Provincial Project of Science and Technology (222102320457).

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Publisher’s Note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations or those of the publisher, the editors, and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank the Pan-pearl Delta ADR Monitoring Platform for providing the data source and the accuracy of the data.

Supplementary Material

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fphar.2022.771953/full#supplementary-material

References

Baldo, B. A., Pham, N. H., and Zhao, Z. (2001). Chemistry of Drug Allergenicity. Curr. Opin. Allergy Clin. Immunol. 1, 327–335. doi:10.1097/01.all.0000011034.96839.aa

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Barnes, J., and Butler, R. (2020). Community Pharmacists' Views and Experiences with ADR Reporting for Complementary Medicines: a Qualitative Study in New Zealand. Drug Saf. 43, 1157–1170. doi:10.1007/s40264-020-00980-x

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Beijer, H. J., and de Blaey, C. J. (2002). Hospitalisations Caused by Adverse Drug Reactions (ADR): a Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies. Pharm. World Sci. 24, 46–54. doi:10.1023/a:1015570104121

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Böttiger, L. E., Furhoff, A. K., and Holmberg, L. (1979). Fatal Reactions to Drugs. Acta Med. Scand. 205, 451–456. doi:10.1111/j.0954-6820.1979.tb06083.x

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Buajordet, I., Ebbesen, J., Erikssen, J., Brørs, O., and Hilberg, T. (2001). Fatal Adverse Drug Events: the Paradox of Drug Treatment. J. Intern. Med. 250, 327–341. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2796.2001.00892.x

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Chyka, P. A. (2000). How many Deaths Occur Annually from Adverse Drug Reactions in the United States? Am. J. Med. 109, 122–130. doi:10.1016/s0002-9343(00)00460-5

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

de Vries, S. T., Denig, P., Ekhart, C., Burgers, J. S., Kleefstra, N., Mol, P. G. M., et al. (2019). Sex Differences in Adverse Drug Reactions Reported to the National Pharmacovigilance Centre in the Netherlands: An Explorative Observational Study. Br. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 85 (7), 1507–1515. doi:10.1111/bcp.13923

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Ebbesen, J., Buajordet, I., Erikssen, J., Brørs, O., Hilberg, T., Svaar, H., et al. (2001). Drug-related Deaths in a Department of Internal Medicine. Arch. Intern. Med. 161, 2317–2323. doi:10.1001/archinte.161.19.2317

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Ferrajolo, C., Sultana, J., Ientile, V., Scavone, C., Scondotto, G., Tari, M., et al. (2019). Gender Differences in Outpatient Pediatric Drug Utilization: a Cohort Study from Southern Italy. Front. Pharmacol. 10, 11. doi:10.3389/fphar.2019.00011

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Gowdey, C. W., and Brennan, M. (1985). Adverse Drug Reaction Reporting Program of the Ontario Medical Association: the First 3 Years First 3 Years. Can. Med. Assoc. J. 132, 19–23.

PubMed Abstract | Google Scholar

Guo, Y. M., Ge, F. L., Song, H. B., Xiong, P., Jing, J., Niu, M., et al. (2021). Relative Risk Analysis of Liver-Related Adverse Drug Reactions in Children Based on China's National Spontaneous Reporting System. J. Pediatr. 234, 85–91. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2021.03.044

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Hartholt, K. A., van der Velde, N., Looman, C. W., Panneman, M. J., Van Beeck, E. F., Patka, P., et al. (2010). Adverse Drug Reactions Related Hospital Admissions in Persons Aged 60 Years and over, The Netherlands, 1981-2007: Less Rapid Increase, Different Drugs. PLoS One 5 (11), e13977. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0013977

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Hwang, T. J., Orenstein, L., Kesselheim, A. S., and Bourgeois, F. T. (2019). Completion Rate and Reporting of Mandatory Pediatric Postmarketing Studies under the US Pediatric Research Equity Act. JAMA Pediatr. 173 (1), 68–74. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2018.3416

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Juntti-Patinen, L., and Neuvonen, P. J. (2002). Drug-related Deaths in a university central Hospital. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 58, 479–482. doi:10.1007/s00228-002-0501-2

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Kardas, P., Urbański, F., Lichwierowicz, A., Chudzyńska, E., Kardas, G., and Czech, M. (2021). Prevalence and Age Structure of Polypharmacy in Poland: Results of the Analysis of the National Real-World Database of 38 Million Citizens. Front. Pharmacol. 12, 655364. doi:10.3389/fphar.2021.655364

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Klepper, M. J., and Edwards, B. (2011). Individual Case Safety Reports-Hhow to Determine the Onset Date of an Adverse Reaction: a Survey. Drug Saf. 34, 299–305. doi:10.2165/11588490-000000000-00000

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Lazarou, J., Pomeranz, B. H., and Corey, P. N. (1998). Incidence of Adverse Drug Reactions in Hospitalized Patients: a Meta-Analysis of Prospective Studies. JAMA 279, 1200–1205. doi:10.1001/jama.279.15.1200

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Leone, R., Sottosanti, L., Luisa Iorio, M., Santuccio, C., Conforti, A., Sabatini, V., et al. (2008). Drug-related Deaths: an Analysis of the Italian Spontaneous Reporting Database. Drug Saf. 31, 703–713. doi:10.2165/00002018-200831080-00007

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Létinier, L., Cossin, S., Mansiaux, Y., Arnaud, M., Salvo, F., Bezin, J., et al. (2019). Risk of Drug-Drug Interactions in Out-Hospital Drug Dispensings in France: Results from the DRUG-Drug Interaction Prevalence Study. Front. Pharmacol. 10, 265. doi:10.3389/fphar.2019.00265

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Li, H., Deng, J., Deng, L., Ren, X., and Xia, J. (2019). Safety Profile of Traditional Chinese Herbal Injection: An Analysis of a Spontaneous Reporting System in China. Pharmacoepidemiol. Drug Saf. 28, 1002–1013. doi:10.1002/pds.4805

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Li, H., Deng, J., Yu, P., Deng, L., and Ren, X. (2020). Gaining Insight into Irrational Off-Label Use of Vidarabine through Analysis of a Spontaneous Reporting System in China. J. Clin. Pharm. Ther. 45, 1301–1311. doi:10.1111/jcpt.13209

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Li, H., Deng, J., Yue, Z., Zhang, Y., and Sun, H. (2015). Detecting Drug-Herbal Interaction Using a Spontaneous Reporting System Database: an Example with Benzylpenicillin and Qingkailing Injection. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 71, 1139–1145. doi:10.1007/s00228-015-1898-8

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Li, H., Wang, S., Yue, Z., Ren, X., and Xia, J. (2018). Traditional Chinese Herbal Injection: Current Status and Future Perspectives. Fitoterapia 129, 249–256. doi:10.1016/j.fitote.2018.07.009

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Linkens, A. E. M. J. H., Milosevic, V., van der Kuy, P. H. M., Damen-Hendriks, V. H., Mestres Gonzalvo, C., and Hurkens, K. P. G. M. (2020). Medication-related Hospital Admissions and Readmissions in Older Patients: an Overview of Literature. Int. J. Clin. Pharm. 42 (5), 1243–1251. doi:10.1007/s11096-020-01040-1

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Liu, B. A., Knowles, S. R., Mittmann, N., Einarson, T., and Shear, N. H. (2001). Reporting of Fatal Adverse Drug Reactions. Can. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 8, 84–88.

Google Scholar

Lombardi, N., Crescioli, G., Bettiol, A., Tuccori, M., Capuano, A., Bonaiuti, R., et al. (2020). Italian Emergency Department Visits and Hospitalizations for Outpatients' Adverse Drug Events: 12-Year Active Pharmacovigilance Surveillance (The MEREAFaPS Study). Front. Pharmacol. 11, 412. doi:10.3389/fphar.2020.00412

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Long, Y. F., and Li, Y. L. (2010). Analysis of Abuse of Injection Behavior under Visual fields of Ethics and its Countermeasures. Chin. Nurs. Res. 24, 2166–2168. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1009-6493.2010.24.002

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Marwitz, K., Jones, S. C., Kortepeter, C. M., Dal Pan, G. J., and Muñoz, M. A. (2020). An Evaluation of Postmarketing Reports with an Outcome of Death in the US FDA Adverse Event Reporting System. Drug Saf. 43, 457–465. doi:10.1007/s40264-020-00908-5

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Mittmann, N., Liu, B. A., Iskedjian, M., Bradley, C. A., Pless, R., Shear, N. H., et al. (1997). Drug-related Mortality in Canada (1984-1994). Pharmacoepidemiol. Drug Saf. 6, 157–168. doi:10.1002/(SICI)1099-1557(199705)6:3<157:AID-PDS260>3.0.CO;2-J

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Montané, E., Arellano, A. L., Sanz, Y., Roca, J., and Farré, M. (2018). Drug-related Deaths in Hospital Inpatients: A Retrospective Cohort Study. Br. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 84, 542–552. doi:10.1111/bcp.13471

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Montané, E., and Castells, X. (2021). Epidemiology of Drug‐related Deaths in European Hospitals: A Systematic Review and Meta‐analysis of Observational Studies. Br. Jnl Clin. Pharma 87, 3659–3671. doi:10.1111/bcp.14799

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Moore, T. J., Cohen, M. R., and Furberg, C. D. (2007). Serious Adverse Drug Events Reported to the Food and Drug Administration, 1998-2005. Arch. Intern. Med. 167, 1752–1759. doi:10.1001/archinte.167.16.1752

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

National Bureau of Statistics of China (2010). Tabulation of the 2010 Populaton Census of the People's republic of China. Available at: : http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/pcsj/rkpc/6rp/indexch.htm (Accessed July 12, 2021).

Google Scholar

Pardo Cabello, A. J., Del Pozo Gavilán, E., Gómez Jiménez, F. J., Mota Rodríguez, C., Luna Del Castillo, J. d. D., and Puche Cañas, E. (2016). Drug-related Mortality Among Inpatients: a Retrospective Observational Study. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 72, 731–736. doi:10.1007/s00228-016-2026-0

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Pardo-Cabello, A. J., Manzano-Gamero, V., Del-Pozo, E., Gómez-Jiménez, F. J., Luna-del Castillo, J. D., and Puche-Cañas, E. (2018). Drug-related Mortality Among Inpatients Admitted in Internal Medicine. An Sist Sanit Navar 41, 339–346. doi:10.23938/ASSN.0381

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Patel, T. K., and Patel, P. B. (2018). Mortality Among Patients Due to Adverse Drug Reactions that lead to Hospitalization: a Meta-Analysis. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 74, 819–832. doi:10.1007/s00228-018-2441-5

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Pirmohamed, M., James, S., Meakin, S., Green, C., Scott, A. K., Walley, T. J., et al. (2004). Adverse Drug Reactions as Cause of Admission to Hospital: Prospective Analysis of 18 820 Patients. BMJ 329, 15–19. doi:10.1136/bmj.329.7456.15

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Powell, J. R., Cook, J., Wang, Y., Peck, R., and Weiner, D. (2021). Drug Dosing Recommendations for All Patients: a Roadmap for Change. Clin. Pharmacol. Ther. 109 (1), 65–72. doi:10.1002/cpt.1923

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Rauch, E., Lagler, F. B., Herkner, H., Gall, W., Sauermann, R., Hetz, S., et al. (2018). A Survey of Medicine Use in Children and Adolescents in Austria. Eur. J. Pediatr. 177 (10), 1479–1487. doi:10.1007/s00431-018-3196-9

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Roberts, R., Rodriguez, W., Murphy, D., and Crescenzi, T. (2003). Pediatric Drug Labeling: Improving the Safety and Efficacy of Pediatric Therapies. JAMA 290 (7), 905–911. doi:10.1001/jama.290.7.905

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Ruiter, R., Visser, L. E., Rodenburg, E. M., Trifiró, G., Ziere, G., and Stricker, B. H. (2012). Adverse Drug Reaction-Related Hospitalizations in Persons Aged 55 Years and over: a Population-Based Study in the Netherlands. Drugs Aging 29 (3), 225–232. doi:10.2165/11599430-000000000-00000

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Salvi, F., Marchetti, A., D'Angelo, F., Boemi, M., Lattanzio, F., and Cherubini, A. (2012). Adverse Drug Events as a Cause of Hospitalization in Older Adults. Drug Saf. 35 (Suppl. 1), 29–45. doi:10.1007/BF03319101

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Streefland, M. B. (2018). Why Are We Still Creating Individual Case Safety Reports? Clin. Ther. 40, 1973–1980. doi:10.1016/j.clinthera.2018.10.012

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Tiaden, J. D., Wenzel, E., Berthold, H. K., and Müller-Oerlinghausen, B. (2005). Adverse Reactions to Anticoagulants and to Antiplatelet Drugs Recorded by the German Spontaneous Reporting System. Semin. Thromb. Hemost. 31, 371–380. doi:10.1055/s-2005-916670

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Vaccheri, A., Castelvetri, C., Esaka, E., Del Favero, A., and Montanaro, N. (2000). Pattern of Antibiotic Use in Primary Health Care in Italy. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 56, 417–425. doi:10.1007/s002280000165

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

van der Hooft, C. S., Sturkenboom, M. C., van Grootheest, K., Kingma, H. J., and Stricker, B. H. (2006). Adverse Drug Reaction-Related Hospitalisations: a Nationwide Study in the Netherlands. Drug Saf. 29, 161–168. doi:10.2165/00002018-200629020-00006

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Venkatesh, S. P. (2010). Medicine Use in Children: a Critical Area. J. Clin. Pediatr. Dent 34 (3), 207–211. doi:10.17796/jcpd.34.3.a1w397x29h436tpt

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Wester, K., Jönsson, A., Spigset, O., and Hägg, S. (2007). Spontaneously Reported Fatal Suspected Adverse Drug Reactions: A 10-Year Survey From Sweden. Pharmacoepidemiol. Drug Saf. 16, 173–180. doi:10.1002/pds.1263

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Zhang, Y. (2010). The Study on the Harmfulness, Causes and Control Strategies Overuse of Injections in the Primary Medical Institutions in Rural Areas of China. Chin. Prim. Health Care 24 (5), 3–6. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1001-568X.2010.05.002

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Zimmerman, K. O., Smith, P. B., McMahon, A. W., Temeck, J., Avant, D., Murphy, D., et al. (2019). Duration of Pediatric Clinical Trials Submitted to the US Food and Drug Administration. JAMA Pediatr. 173 (1), 60–67. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2018.3227

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Zoppi, M., Braunschweig, S., Kuenzi, U. P., Maibach, R., and Hoigné, R. (2000). Incidence of Lethal Adverse Drug Reactions in the Comprehensive Hospital Drug Monitoring, a 20-year Survey, 1974-1993, Based on the Data of Berne/St. Gallen. Eur. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 56, 427–430. doi:10.1007/s002280000158

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar