Stormwater best management practices: Experimental evaluation of chemical cocktails mobilized by freshwater salinization syndrome

Galella, Joseph G.; Kaushal, Sujay S.; Mayer, Paul M.; Maas, Carly M.; Shatkay, Ruth R.; Stutzke, Robert A.

doi:10.3389/fenvs.2023.1020914

ORIGINAL RESEARCH article

Front. Environ. Sci., 04 April 2023

Sec. Biogeochemical Dynamics

Volume 11 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fenvs.2023.1020914

This article is part of the Research Topic Biogeochemical Dynamics in Urban Systems: Interactions, Feedbacks, and Cumulative Impacts View all 9 articles

Stormwater best management practices: Experimental evaluation of chemical cocktails mobilized by freshwater salinization syndrome

Ruth R. Shatkay¹

Robert A. Stutzke¹

¹Department of Geology & Earth System Science Interdisciplinary Center, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, United States
²US Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Center for Public Health and Environmental Assessment, Corvallis, OR, United States

Freshwater Salinization Syndrome (FSS) refers to the suite of physical, biological, and chemical impacts of salt ions on the degradation of natural, engineered, and social systems. Impacts of FSS on mobilization of chemical cocktails has been documented in streams and groundwater, but little research has focused on the effects of FSS on stormwater best management practices (BMPs) such as: constructed wetlands, bioswales, ponds, and bioretention. However emerging research suggests that stormwater BMPs may be both sources and sinks of contaminants, shifting seasonally with road salt applications. We conducted lab experiments to investigate this premise; replicate water and soil samples were collected from four distinct stormwater feature types (bioretention, bioswale, constructed wetlands and retention ponds) and were used in salt incubation experiments conducted under six different salinities with three different salts (NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂). Increased salt concentrations had profound effects on major and trace element mobilization, with all three salts showing significant positive relationships across nearly all elements analyzed. Across all sites, mean salt retention was 34%, 28%, and 26% for Na⁺, Mg²⁺ and Ca²⁺ respectively, and there were significant differences among stormwater BMPs. Salt type showed preferential mobilization of certain elements. NaCl mobilized Cu, a potent toxicant to aquatic biota, at rates over an order of magnitude greater than both CaCl₂ and MgCl₂. Stormwater BMP type also had a significant effect on elemental mobilization, with ponds mobilizing significantly more Mn than other sites. However, salt concentration and salt type consistently had significant effects on mean concentrations of elements mobilized across all stormwater BMPs (p < 0.05), suggesting that processes such as ion exchange mobilize metals mobilize metals and salt ions regardless of BMP type. Our results suggest that decisions regarding the amounts and types of salts used as deicers can have significant effects on reducing contaminant mobilization to freshwater ecosystems.

Introduction

Freshwater Salinization Syndrome (FSS) is an emerging global pollution problem with both human health and environmental risks (Kaushal et al., 2005; Cañedo-Argüelles et al., 2013; Kaushal et al., 2018b, 2019; Thorslund et al., 2021; Kaushal et al., 2022b). FSS occurs when anthropogenic sources of salt ions, like deicers, mining waste, fertilizers, sewage, and weathering of concrete raise the salinity and alkalinity of freshwater (Kaushal et al., 2017, 2018b; Galella et al., 2021). FSS has increasingly affected temperate areas of the United States and Europe over the past century corresponding to increased road salt use (Corsi et al., 2010; Dugan et al., 2017; Kaushal et al., 2019; Stets et al., 2020; Kaushal et al., 2020, 2022b). For example, road salt sales in the US have increased from 164,000 tons in 1940 to over 22 million tons in 2019 (Abolfazli and Strom 2022). In temperate regions, extremely high salinity is sometimes caused by road salting during winter precipitation events (Kaushal et al., 2005; Moore et al., 2020; Galella et al., 2021). Elevated salinity from FSS can act to corrode infrastructure, increase aquatic fauna mortality, and destabilize soil aggregate structures (Green et al., 2008a, c; Mahrosh et al., 2014; Kaushal et al., 2018b). In urban streams, high salinity can mobilize major and trace elements. Positive correlations have been found between specific conductance and mobilization of base cations and trace metals like Cu, Sr²⁺, and Mn (Amrhein et al., 1992; Löfgren 2001; Kaushal et al., 2019; Galella et al., 2021)¹. Ion exchange is thought to be a major driver of contaminant mobilization, but redox reactions and Na⁺ dispersion of colloids likely also play a role (Kaushal et al., 2018a; Kinsman-Costello et al., 2022). Increases in the magnitude and frequency of road salt pulses may also lead to the retention and release of multiple contaminants from urban stormwater best management practices (BMPs) which are ubiquitous in urban landscapes (Kaushal et al., 2022b). Stormwater BMPs, also known as green stormwater infrastructure or structural BMPs, are generally designed with the goal of reducing soil erosion, attenuating peak runoff from impervious surfaces, and increasing groundwater connectivity (Yu et al., 2013; Loperfido et al., 2014). Previous research has shown that stormwater BMPs can be both sources and sinks of various elements, changing seasonally with road salt application (Barbier et al., 2018).

A recent study estimates that between 2016 and 2036, the US will spend $19.2 billion (US) on stormwater infrastructure (Throwe et al., 2020). Modern stormwater BMPs such as bioretention cells and constructed wetlands often act to retain nutrients and attenuate peak discharge (Davis 2008; Collins et al., 2010; Passeport et al., 2013). Though the efficacy of nutrient removal and flood prevention varies from site to site, there is generally a net positive effect of stormwater BMPs on contaminant retention (Davis 2008; Koch et al., 2014). Less is known, however, about the effectiveness of stormwater BMPs for retaining the chemical cocktails mobilized by FSS (Kaushal et al., 2022a, b). Chemical cocktails are an anthropogenic consequence of FSS, defined by an increase in the mobilization of inorganic and organic chemicals combinations both chronically and acutely due to salt pollution (Kaushal et al., 2018a). Specifically in this research we will focus on chromatographic chemical cocktails (ions mobilized and retained on soil exchange sites) and reactive chemical cocktails (nutrients and redox sensitive elements) (Kaushal et al., 2018a). Because salinization mobilizes chemical contaminants from sediments (Duan and Kaushal 2015; Haq et al., 2018; Kaushal et al., 2019), these salt ions may unintentionally affect the functioning of stormwater BMPs to release harmful ions and metals (Semadeni-Davies 2006; Williams et al., 2016; Barbier et al., 2018).

Ion exchange in soils and sediments is a major driver of chemical cocktail mobilization during FSS, but changes in redox conditions, pH, and solubility, enhanced microbial activity, complexation, and others process likely play a role (Kaushal et al., 2018b, 2020, 2021; 2022a). Anthropogenic inputs of Na⁺, Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, and K⁺ ions contribute to freshwater salinization across land uses (Kaushal et al., 2017; Moore et al., 2017). Positively charged metal ions such as Cu, Mn, Sr²⁺, and Hg are often ionically bonded to negatively charged exchange sites on colloid particles in sediment and soil. Monovalent and divalent base cations, often introduced through road salting, act to displace metals and other cations into solution (Kaushal et al., 2019; Morel et al., 2020; Galella et al., 2021). Metals are also often transported as aqueous complexes with salt ions, forming metal-ligand bonds (Gaillardet et al., 2003; Kaushal et al., 2020). Chloro-complexation may also play a role in mobilization as Cl⁻ can increase Cd²⁺ and Pb solubility (Kaushal et al., 2019). Combinations of road salts may be more harmful than using only NaCl. For example, a 3:2 ratio of CaCl₂ to NaCl (by weight), commonly used in road salting, was shown to mobilize greater quantities of As, Pb and Hg, from exposed soils than did NaCl alone (Sun et al., 2015).

In addition to other salt ions and trace metals, FSS has also been shown to mobilize nutrients and organic matter (Green et al., 2008b; Haq et al., 2018; Inamdar et al., 2022). As salt ions accumulate in soils, ammonium, nitrate, and organic nitrogen can be mobilized by ion exchange and other processes influencing relative proportions of inorganic vs. organic forms (Hale and Groffman 2006; Green et al., 2008b). The process of nitrification and denitrification and other forms of microbial activity may be also affected due to changes in pH (Hale and Groffman 2006; Green et al., 2008b). As a result, leaching of nitrate to local waterways increases in salt-impacted soils (Green et al., 2008b). Road salt can also affect organic matter mobility, particularly when using NaCl (Green et al., 2008a). Organic matter naturally helps maintain soil structure and aggregate stability (Peinemann et al., 2005). Increased soil aggregate stability may be caused by the cation exchange capacity (CEC) of the organic matter present, the preference of Ca²⁺ ion exchange sites over Na⁺, and the ability of soil organic matter to donate protons (Peinemann et al., 2005). Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ help bind organic matter, but when mobilized through base cation exchange with Na⁺ from road salting, soil aggregate structure can begin to fail, mobilizing organic matter (Green et al., 2008a, c). Initially, increases in salinity act to temporarily disperse organic matter, as soil aggregates break apart (Green et al., 2008a, c). If this increased salinity becomes chronic, soil pH can decrease, however. Through the mobile anion effect (this is when negatively charged ions move through the soil profile), bonded base cations can be mobilized along with anions, exhausting buffering capacity) (Green et al., 2008a, c). Elevated concentrations of NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂ in streams in response to road salting can also increase flocculation of suspended sediments and soils (Abolfazli and Strom 2022), leading to larger soil aggregates, increased deposition, and compromising benthic ecosystems (Abolfazli and Strom 2022). Flocculation increases with ion concentrations and is caused by cations (particularly divalent and multivalent cations) decreasing the thickness of the double layer (the two layers of charge surrounding an object), allowing for the attraction force to overcome the repulsion force, forming aggregates (Abolfazli and Strom 2022).

Because stormwater BMPs are ubiquitous in urban landscapes (and also key features along urban hydrologic flowpaths (Kaushal and Belt 2012)), it is critical to understand how these features are affected by FSS and how contaminant mobilization impacts urban water quality. With many different design strategies available, we seek to understand how different stormwater BMPs mobilize or retain chemical cocktails during road salting events and how different road salt types influence the chemical cocktails released. This research quantifies how different salt ions, salt concentrations, and stormwater BMPs affect the mobilization of carbon, nutrients, and major and trace elements. Our study aims to provide a better understanding of mobilization thresholds and the behavior of salts in stormwater BMPs. We assess whether these stormwater management features are potential salinity management tools or if salt adversely affects their function. Stormwater BMPs at the University of Maryland, College Park, Maryland, United States, 38°59′9.53″N, 76°56′33.21″W were chosen for this study. Bioretention cells, bioswales, wetlands, and ponds were chosen as sampling sites to test a variety of different stormwater BMPs (Table 1).

TABLE 1

TABLE 1. Characteristics of stormwater management BMPs sampled in this study. Samples were collected at the University of Maryland College Park 38°59'9.53"N, 76°56'33.21"W.

We believe that salt type, salt concentration, and stormwater BMP type are key factors which control the mobilization of chemical cocktails from stormwater BMP sediments into aqueous form (Semadeni-Davies 2006; Gill et al., 2017; Snodgrass et al., 2017; Barbier et al., 2018; Burgis et al., 2020; McGuire and Judd 2020; Knox et al., 2021; Maas et al., 2021; Kaushal et al., 2022b). We hypothesize that increasing salt concentration will increase mobilization of base cations and metals into solution. We hypothesize that different salt types used in incubations (NaCl, CaCl₂ and MgCl₂) will preferentially mobilize certain major and trace elements. We hypothesize that the different stormwater BMP types studied will have statistically distinct cation retention and elemental mobilization from one another. Our results have implications for guiding decisions regarding the amounts and types of road salt ions used and their potential to reduce contaminant mobilization in the environment.

Study sites

Site descriptions for stormwater management BMPs

The stormwater BMPs sampled during this study were located on the University of Maryland College Park campus, in the Paint Branch watershed nested within the broader Anacostia River watershed. Soils, water quality, stormwater management, and hydrology within the Paint Branch watershed have been described extensively in our previous papers (Haq et al., 2018; Kaushal et al., 2019; Kaushal et al., 2022b; Wood et al., 2022) and elsewhere (Davis 2008; Davis et al., 2009, 2011; DiBlasi et al., 2009; Jones and Davis 2013). Four types of stormwater BMPs (bioretention cells, bioswales, wetlands, and ponds) were sampled, in pairs for a total of eight sampling sites (Table 1). Bioretention features are characterized by a base of sand, soil, or other type of organic media that treats stormwater while also allowing for infiltration, topped by mulch, vegetation, and an area for runoff pooling and overflow (Davis et al., 2009). Bioswales are similarly constructed except they are usually sloped to convey water through the system efficiently (ASLA 2022). Constructed wetlands are often characterized by a base liner, topped with soil, sand, gravel, or other organic material with shallow standing water, an assemblage of hydrophilic plants and planned surface and subsurface flow (Davis 1995). Retention wet ponds are often built to store water, prevent flooding, and reduce peak storm discharge. In Maryland retention ponds are often 1.8–2.4 m deep with accommodations for anticipated flooding (10 and 100 years) and adequate overflow spillways (Schueler and Claytor 2009). Current regulations require ponds to have vegetative cover, but older structures may be concrete lined. (Schueler and Claytor 2009). Henceforth, we refer to the sites as: Bioretention #1 and #2, Bioswale #1 and #2, Wetland #1 and #2, and Pond #1 and #2. Sites were chosen based on similar characteristics. Some sites were ephemeral and four (Bioswales #1 and #2, and Bioretention #1 and #2) had no surface water when sampled. For these sites, water from nearby Paint Branch and Campus Creek were collected. Surface water for the remaining four sites was collected in situ from the stormwater BMPs.

Bioswales #1 and #2 were constructed in 2017 to help manage runoff from new building construction and a new ∼2,500 m² parking lot. Three bioswales were constructed but the two most similar in size were sampled for this study (Figure 1). Cells (the discreet vegetated units which facilitate filtration, storage, and groundwater connection) were constructed of a top layer (3–8 cm) of mulch overlaying a porous soil matrix (Davis et al., 2011). Water tolerant species were planted in this area to promote evapotranspiration and slow overland flow of runoff.

FIGURE 1

FIGURE 1. Stormwater management features sampled across the UMD campus. Duplicate bioswale, bioretention, wetland, and pond sites were selected.

Bioretention site #1 and #2 were built 3 years apart from one another. Bioretention #1 was constructed in 2006 to help drain a neighboring ∼30,000 m² parking lot. The site is the smallest of the stormwater BMPs sampled, with a 10-m concrete inlet collecting runoff from the parking lot and an outlet discharging into Campus Creek. Organic-rich soil with overlaying grasses was present in the conduit. Bioretention #2, built in 2003 to treat runoff from a 2,000 m² parking lot (Davis et al., 2011), contains two separate, parallel cells which originally contained porous soil covered with a 3–8 cm layer of decomposed hardwood mulch (Davis et al., 2011). In order to increase biological diversity, evapotranspiration, and pollutant uptake, trees, shrubs, and grasses were planted (Davis et al., 2011).

Wetland #1 was constructed and Wetland #2 was accidental (an unintentional artefact of management) (sensu Maas et al., 2021). During 2001 and 2002, Wetland #1 was installed to help control runoff from a 17,000 m² indoor stadium facility at the University of Maryland (UMD) and neighboring 8,500 m² parking lot. Wetland #1 contains two parallel cells containing individual water inlets, each with a ponded section with boulders and cobbles to help reduce erosion and a shallow marsh area populated with wetland flora. Wetland #2 was originally designed as a runoff pond sometime between 1989 and 1994 to capture runoff from four neighboring buildings on the UMD campus and three small parking lots. After ∼30 years of gradually infilling through slack water sedimentation, the site has transitioned to a heavily vegetated wetland with <10% open water.

Ponds #1 and #2 were similar in design but differed in age. Pond #1 was constructed between 2002 and 2005 to accept drainage from the UMD’s 25,000 m² School of Music building complex. The site contains a riparian buffer planted around the lake’s border to reduce its temperature and limit overland flow. The oldest site sampled was Pond #2, constructed prior to 1988 and further altered in 2001. Pond #2 has high banks and high-water depth, with abundant wetland flora and fauna (e.g., amphibians).

Experimental design of salinization experiments

For this study we sampled 8 separate stormwater BMPs consisting of pairs of stormwater BMP site types (bioretention cell 1 and 2, bioswale 1 and 2, wetland 1 and 2, and pond 1 and 2). The stormwater BMPs were all located within the Uinversity of Maryland College Park Campus but separate from each other hydrologically. Sediment samples were collected along the hydrologic flowpaths of the stormwater BMPs selected. Individual samples were homogenized in the field and later subdivided into replicate batches for use in salinization incubations. Similar to our previous methods in (Duan and Kaushal 2015; Haq et al., 2018; Kaushal et al., 2022), ∼1-kg of sediment was removed from each site with a clean plastic trowel and placed into a new zip-top bag. Metal tools were not used so as to not introduce additional metals to the sediment. At least two L of surface water were also collected (via acid-washed HPDE Nalgene bottles; no headspace). If no surface water was available within the site itself, the closest neighboring body of water was used as a collection point. Both sediment and water samples were put in a chilled cooler for transport back to the laboratory and chilled at 4°C (Haq et al., 2018). In order to increase homogeneity, the sediment samples were sieved through a 4-mm sieve and the fines were utilized for incubation analysis (Duan and Kaushal 2015; Haq et al., 2018). Sixty grams of sediment fines and 100 ml of unfiltered stream water from each site were added to duplicate acid-washed glass Erlenmeyer flasks. The vertical water column created therein simulates a vertical water column with both a sediment-water and water-air interface.

Salt incubations of sieved sediment and unfiltered water from each stormwater BMP were prepared with three different salt types commonly used as road deicers, NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl2. Six different treatment levels were chosen with salt quantities being normalized to 1, 2.5, 5, and 10 g Cl⁻/L for each salt type, along with ultra-high purity Milli-Q and stream water blanks for a total of six treatment levels (Table 2). The range of salinities were selected based upon the peak salinity readings within the Washington DC and Baltimore MD metro areas, with the highest concentration of added Cl⁻ being just over half that of seawater. Long-term chloride concentrations in Baltimore streams reached above 5 g/L (Kaushal et al., 2005) and, in wetlands and ponds, Cl⁻ concentrations high as 13.5 g/L were observed (Hintz and Relyea 2019).

TABLE 2

TABLE 2. Quantity of NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂ added to unfiltered stream water for each incubation concentration. Incubation concentrations are normalized to 1, 2.5, 5, and 10 g of chloride per liter.

Each site had a duplicate sample prepared for each salt concentration including Milli-Q and stream water blanks. All sediment aliquots for each site were incubated together with their duplicates within 12 h of field collection. Flasks were loosely capped with an aluminum foil shield used to block out any ambient light during incubation. Flasks were placed on a shaking table and slowly agitated for 24 h at a room temperature of ∼20°C. Agitation during incubation simulated water flow through the stormwater BMP features. Post-incubation, water was carefully removed from the flask using a pipette to avoid undue disturbance to the sediment. Water was immediately filtered through an ashed 0.7-micron glass fiber filter and stored in a refrigerator at 4°C or frozen for later analysis. A portion of the filtered incubation water was diluted to <0.5 g Cl⁻ and acidified in a 60 ml acid-washed HDPE Nalgene bottle to a concentration of 0.5% metal grade nitric acid. Acidification made the sample shelf stable at room temperature for 6 months and allowed for later analysis via inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry ICP-OES (Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory 1996). ICP-OES analysis will allow for major and trace elemental analysis of the incubation water.

Every sampling site nominally had 12 samples prepared per salt type or 36 samples in total. When all sampling sites are included, 288 samples were prepared in total but 4 accidently became cross-contaminated and could not be used for further analysis, making the final sample count 284. The quantity of salt added is not subtracted from subsequent ICP-OES analysis results. For clarity a graphic of the experimental design used in this study is included in (Supplementary Figure S1).

Sampling a stormwater management feature during a snow event

An opportunity to study real world chemical cocktail formation in response to road salt applications in a stormwater BMP presented itself during the winter months of this study. In order to corroborate some of our incubation results, an ISCO 3700 water sampler was used to sample the surface water of Wetland #2 during a snow event (and road salt applications) between 1/28/22 and 1/29/22 (Teledyne 2022). Samples were immediately collected and kept chilled at 4°C until filtered through an ashed 0.7-micron glass fiber filter. A 60 ml aliquot of the sample was transferred to an acid-washed HDPE Nalgene bottle and acidified to a concentration of 0.5% metal grade nitric acid. Acidification made the sample shelf stable at room temperature for 6 months and allowed for later analysis via inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry ICP-OES (Environmental Monitoring Systems Laboratory 1996).

Water chemistry analyses

Base cation and trace metal concentrations in the acidified water samples were measured via ICP-OES on a Shimadzu Elemental Spectrometer (ICPE-9800; Shimadzu, Columbia, Maryland, United States). Base cation measurements were analyzed in radial mode (across a plasma flame), and trace metals measurements, were analyzed in axial mode (down plasma flame). The instrument was calibrated to the range of trace metals that are commonly observed in urban streams via the utilization of an Inorganic Ventures standard.

Dissolved organic carbon (DOC), measured as non-purgeable organic carbon, dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) and total dissolved nitrogen (TDN) were measured using a Shimadzu Total Organic Carbon Analyzer (TOC-V CPH/CPN) total nitrogen module, TNM-1 (Haq et al., 2018).

Statistical methods

In order to elucidate the relationships between salt application and elemental mobilization, linear regressions were performed in Microsoft Excel (Figure 3 and Table 6) with Cl⁻ concentration as the independent variable and elemental concentration in mg/L as the dependent variable. Retention of Na⁺, Ca²⁺, and Mg²⁺ was determined by calculating the concentration of Na⁺, Ca²⁺, and Mg²⁺ added to the incubation aliquots in mg/L and subtracting the concentration (in mg/L) measured after 24 h of incubation. The quantity retained (mg/L) was plotted against the initial concentration added (Figure 2) to indicate how much of the cation added is sorbed onto colloids and other sediment particles.

FIGURE 2

FIGURE 2. Na, Ca²⁺, and Mg²⁺ retention after NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂ incubations. The orange dash line indicates 100% adsorption, and the blue circles are the measured values in mg/L.

The dataset was found to be normally distributed using a Quantile – Quantile plot (QQ plot) and density plot of residuals (Supplementary Figures S2, S3). Despite our dataset having limited replicates (duplicate samples) three-way ANOVA was selected as our primary statistical analysis. Three-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed with concentrations of respective elements as dependent variables in models that included all treatments (stormwater BMP type, salt type, or salt concentration levels) as independent variables. Main treatment and interaction effects with alpha level (p ≤ 0.05) were considered statistically significant and indicating that the major or trace element analyzed increased in concentration (i.e., mobilized) due to stormwater BMP type, salt type, and salt concentration or interactions thereof. For three-way ANOVAs, Tukey’s Honestly Significant Difference test was used to make pair-wise comparisons among means for respective treatments (stormwater BMP type, salt type, salt concentration level) and interactions among treatments to determine which BMP type, salt type, salt concentration, or combination thereof influenced elemental mobilization. Data were analyzed using R-Studio, software.

Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to explore multivariate patterns in major and trace element mobilization. The PCA was completed in MATLAB, where datasets were normalized to correct for the different scales of the data used. PCA was used to illustrate the changing correlations between major and trace elements based on salt type used in the incubation. Distinct groupings of elements represent distinct chemical cocktails mobilized by NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂; any element within a 90^o angle of one another is considered positively correlated in a PCA analysis, and any element 180^o opposed to one another is non-correlated.

Results

Retention of salt ions among stormwater BMPs

We calculated retention of Na⁺, Mg²⁺ and Ca²⁺ by comparing the known concentration of each cation in the water added to each incubation to the measured concentration in post incubation aliquots. The retention shown in mg/L (Figure 2) indicates how much of the cation is retained on cation exchange sites in the stormwater BMPs sediment. Na⁺, Mg²⁺ and Ca²⁺ retention varied based on the type of salt added, salt concentration, and the stormwater BMP sampled. Retention increased with increasing concentration of Na⁺, Mg²⁺ and Ca²⁺ added in all but one sampling site. At Wetland #2, Mg²⁺ retention decreased as more was added, 103 mg/L was retained of the initial 342.8 mg/L dose (1 g Cl⁻/L) and retention decreased to 47.8 mg/L of the initial 3428 mg/L dose (10 g Cl⁻/L). This may be caused by locally high Mg²⁺ levels present in the sediment at Wetland #2 as elevated Mg²⁺ levels were present in NaCl incubations of the site. Mean Na⁺ retention was the highest at 1011 mg/L (34%), likely due to it being monovalent, with divalent Mg²⁺ and Ca²⁺ averaging 690 mg/L (28%) and 357 mg/L (26%) retention, respectively. Using three-way ANOVA analysis and Tukey’s Honestly-Significant-Difference tests, retention was found to be significantly different between salt types (Supplementary Table S2, S3). Stormwater BMP type was also found to be a significant factor in retention with bioswale sites significantly retaining the most salt cations (mean retention 914 mg/L) and wetland sites significantly retaining the least salt cations (mean retention 543 mg/L). Bioretention and pond sites retained similar quantities of base cations (mean retention 646 mg/L and 633 mg/L respectively) making them statistically indistinct from one another.

Our results showed that cation exchange sites could become saturated at elevated salt levels. In 79% of incubations, base cation retention decreased or plateaued with increasing salt concentration, suggesting that cation exchange sites on colloids and organic matter became saturated. The remaining 21% of incubations showed increasing cation retention with increasing salinity. If saturation is reached on soil exchange sites, the stormwater BMP may no longer be able to reduce the effects of salinization downstream and any metals will be mobilized into solution.

Mobilization of elements across salt concentrations, salt types, and site types

Significant mobilization was observed in salt ions, metals, DIC, DOC, and TDN across stormwater BMP types, salt concentrations, and salt types (Tables 3, 4, 5, 6, Figure 3, and Supplementary Table S2). Results from the three-way ANOVA indicated that stormwater BMP type was a significant factor in major and trace element mobilization, with B, Ba²⁺, Fe, K⁺, and Mg²⁺ Mn, Na⁺, Sr²⁺, DIC, DOC, and TDN concentrations all significantly related to the type of stormwater BMP sampled (Tables 3, 5). Significantly less DIC, DOC, TDN, and Ba²⁺, and more B and K⁺ were mobilized in bioswale incubations than in the other stormwater BMP types (Table 5). Significantly more Mn was mobilized at the pond sites (Table 5). Significantly more DIC, DOC, and TDN was mobilized at Bioretention #1 and #2 sites than other features studied. Even within a stormwater BMP type, there was sometimes large variation in mobilization response, possibly due to differences in pH, organic matter, clay content, soil type, or anthropogenic pollution sources (Kaushal et al., 2022b). For example, significantly more Mn was mobilized in Pond #1 than in Pond #2 across all salts tested (NaCl, CaCl₂ and MgCl₂).

TABLE 3

TABLE 3. Three-way ANOVA analysis data assessing main effects of stormwater BMP type, salt type and salt concentration on resulting elemental mobilization. Major and trace elemental analysis is shown, along with dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC), dissolved organic carbon as non-purgeable organic carbon (DOC), and total dissolved nitrogen (TDN). Significant p values are denoted by bold typeface.

TABLE 4

TABLE 4. Tukey’s Honestly-Significant-Difference test was used to compare mean elemental mobilization in the three-way ANOVAs across different salts (NaCl, CaCl₂, MgCl₂). Mean mobilization rates for a given major or trace element share a common letter in the post hoc column when they are not statistically different from one another (p > 0.05).

TABLE 5

TABLE 5. Tukey’s Honestly-Significant-Difference test was used to make pair-wise comparisons among mean elemental mobilization in the three-way ANOVAs across BMP type (Bioswale, Bioretention, Pond, Wetland). Mean mobilization rates for a given major or trace element share a common letter in the post hoc column when they are not statistically different from one another (p > 0.05).

TABLE 6

TABLE 6. Linear regression analysis of elemental concentration to Cl⁻ concentration added in incubations. R² results are color coded from white to blue indicating high R² and white indicating low R². Significant cells are shown in bold typeface (p-values < 0.05).

FIGURE 3

FIGURE 3. Elements mobilized by salt type and concentration. Scales are matching between salt types to better illustrate changes in mobilization by salt type. Inserts in the upper left corner of select graphs better show mobilization in otherwise flattened curves. For visual clarity, the X axis is plotted as a function of discrete salt treatment levels and not continuous concentrations producing what appear to be curvilinear trend lines, however, relationships are linear.

Salt type had significant treatment effects across all elements except Mn and Fe, causing significantly increased mobilization after incubation with NaCl, CaCl₂ and MgCl₂ (Tables 3, 5). Preferential mobilization of elements with salt type was observed, the most notable of which was NaCl mobilizing more than 10 times the quantity of Cu than MgCl₂ or CaCl₂ (Table 4 and Figure 7). NaCl also mobilized significantly less Ba and significantly more B, DOC, and TDN than other Salts. CaCl₂ also mobilized significantly more (2.4 times more Sr²⁺ than MgCl₂ and 4.1 times more Sr²⁺) than NaCl (Table 4). CaCl₂ also mobilized significantly less DOC than other salts tested. Increasing salt concentration significantly increased mobilization of every analyte other than Fe, regardless of salt type tested (Tables 3, 5).

PCA results show formation of chemical cocktails

Principal Component Analysis (PCA) results showed distinct patterns of elemental mobilization across salt type and concentration (Figures 4A–C). When plotted by salt type, the X-axis explained ∼40–60% of variance and the Y-axis explained ∼20% of the variance for all three plots. NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂ incubations all exhibited correlation between Na⁺, Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, K⁺, Cu, and Sr²⁺ as they were clustered within 90^o (Figures 4A–C). Among the NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂ incubations, Mn was the only element not considered correlated, possibly due to mobilization through redox reactions. CaCl₂ mobilized Sr²⁺ most readily (Figures 3, 4) with Ca²⁺ and Sr²⁺ being tightly clustered regardless of the salt used for the incubation. The clustering between Sr²⁺ and Ca²⁺ is noted in Figures 4A–C with a blue circle. Cu and Na also showed a similar clustering, denoted with a red circle (Figure 4A). Increased salt concentrations show heightened mobilization of chemical cocktails in Figure 5. NaCl, MgCl₂ and CaCl₂ incubations at Bioswale, Bioretention, and Pond sites (respectively) all showed greater clustering and correlation between Na⁺, Ca²⁺, Mg²⁺, K⁺, Cu, and Sr²⁺ at “high” concentration incubations (2.5–10 g/L salt) than at “low” concentration incubations (Milli-Q to 1 g/L salt).

FIGURE 4

FIGURE 4. PCA plots showing chemical cocktails mobilized by different salts. All results indicate chemical cocktail dispersion with 6 of the 7 elements analyzed being correlated with the Na, Ca²⁺, or Mg²⁺ added during incubations. Panel (A) shows NaCl incubation results, which illustrate Sr-Ca and Cu-Na co-mobility. Panel (B) shows CaCl₂ incubation results illustrating Sr-Ca and Cu-Na co-mobility. Panel (C) shows MgCl₂ incubation results illustrating Sr-Ca co-mobility.

FIGURE 5

FIGURE 5. PCA plots showing chemical cocktail mobilization at low (Milli-Q to 1 g/L) and high (2.5–10 g/L) concentrations for NaCl, CaCl₂ and MgCl₂. Bioswale 1, Bioretention 2, and Pond 1 are used as examples to show this phenomenon is not isolated to one stormwater BMP. The formation of chemical cocktails is highlighted by red circles in the high concentration PCAs. Plots in column (A) are of low concentration and plots in column (B) are of high concentration.

Discussion

All stormwater BMP types showed elemental mobilization by simulated road salting. This demonstrates that chemical cocktails could be formed in stormwater BMPs under elevated salinity, potentially affecting areas downstream. Increased salt concentration led to increased mobilization of all elements tested except for Fe (Table 3 and Table 6). Fe is often more readily mobilized through redox reactions instead of base cation exchange, explaining its lack of significance. Mn can also be mobilized by redox reactions similarly to Fe, but Mn has been shown to also be mobilized by cation exchange, especially if initial soil pH is low (Wen 2012). Furthermore, B, Ba²⁺, Ca²⁺, Cu, K⁺, Mg²⁺, Mn, Na⁺, Sr²⁺, DIC, DOC, and TDN all showed increased mobilization with increased concentration over all salt types (Table 3, Table 4 and Figure 3). Site type influenced mobilization of key elements with significantly less DIC, DOC, TDN, and Ba²⁺, and more B and K⁺ mobilized in bioswale incubations than in the other stormwater BMP types (Table 5). Increased retention of nitrogenand organic matter may be due to site composition or potentially age as the bioswales are the youngest site in the study by over a decade. Significantly more DIC, DOC, and TDN was mobilized at Bioretention #1 and #2 than other features studied. As these sites drain the largest area into smallest stormwater BMP footprint, they may have diminished CEC (as evidenced by their significantly diminished retention compared to bioswale sites). Previous site history also may play a role in chemical cocktail mobilization as significantly more Mn was mobilized in Pond #1 than in Pond #2, reaching concentrations of up to 36 mg/L. Future studies with a greater number of site replicates may elucidate whether elevated Mn is common in ponds or if this was an isolated phenomenon.

Incubation results are consistent with field results from Galella et al. (2021), which found chemical cocktail mobilization of Ca²⁺, K⁺, Na⁺, Mg²⁺, Cu, Mn and Sr²⁺ during road salting events in urban streams using routine sampling and high-frequency sensors. This suggests that urban streams and stormwater BMPs (bioswales, bioretention sites, wetlands and ponds) behave more similarly to one another with respect to base cation source and sink dynamics than has been suggested in previous literature (Semadeni-Davies 2006; Gill et al., 2017; Barbier et al., 2018; Burgis et al., 2020; Knox et al., 2021; Maas et al., 2021). Stormwater ponds had previously been found to retain metals (Gill et al., 2017; Knox et al., 2021) but at a decreased efficiency (∼50% summer performance) in the winter after roadsalt input (Semadeni-Davies 2006). Stormwater ponds were also found to mobilize base cations after road salting events (Barbier et al., 2018). Though stormwater BMPs do offer excellent conditions for decreasing peak discharge and organic matter and nutrient pollution, stormwater BMPs may be sources rather than sinks of metals and cations during road salting events (Kaushal et al., 2022a; Kaushal et al., 2022b), potentially leading to increased salt and chemical cocktail contamination of surface and groundwater (Kaushal et al., 2019; Burgis et al., 2020; Maas et al., 2021).

Variations in ion retention and release among stormwater BMPs

Our results suggest that stormwater BMPs are capable of retaining salt ions. Na⁺ was retained significantly more than Ca²⁺ or Mg²⁺ across all stormwater BMP types (Supplementary Table S3). The elevated Na⁺ retention measured may be caused by its smaller ionic radius, Na⁺ dispersion, and flocculation (Green SophieM. et al., 2008; Kaushal et al., 2019, 2020). Diminishing percent retention with increasing salt concentration indicates that cation exchange sites were being exhausted and less salt was retained (Figure 2). BMP type also affected retention significantly with biowsale sites retaining the most salt, followed by bioretention, pond and wetland sites. Bioswale sites retained significantly more cations (on average 141% more) than bioretention sites. This may be due to differences in construction or site age as the bioswale sites sampled are the youngest studied by more than a decade.

While they are an effective sink of Na⁺, Mg²⁺ and Ca²⁺, through cation exchange, stormwater BMPs are also a simultaneous source of other base cations and metals (Figure 3) (Kaushal et al., 2022b). Other studies indicate that there is significant retention of various base cations and metals in stormwater ponds (Semadeni-Davies 2006; Barbier et al., 2018), wetlands (Gill et al., 2017; Knox et al., 2021), accidental wetlands (Maas et al., 2021), bioswales and bioretention features (Burgis et al., 2020), but less work has directly analyzed the impacts of salt ions on ion exchange and release of contaminants (Kaushal et al., 2022). The potential for retention or release of contaminants can be influenced by site-specific characteristics, such as a hypersaline layer developing only in deeper sections of stormwater ponds (Semadeni-Davies 2006), or wetlands delaying peak discharge and therefore lessening peak salinity (Maas et al., 2021). Below, we discuss potential impacts of these characteristics on retention and release of salts observed in this study.

While we couldn’t measure all factors contributing to retention in the lab and the field, groundwater storage could be an important mechanism for salt retention (Cooper et al., 2014), and we observed elevated salt concentrations in the stormwater BMP that persisted over time in the field (Figure 6). Field data during and after actual road salt events can be less common in the literature due to the difficulty of winter sampling. Increased groundwater infiltration is a design strategy implemented at all stormwater BMPs studied, which suggested that similar groundwater plumes may also be present. In similar studies, when wetland soils were experimentally flushed with 2.5–5 g Cl/L NaCl, soils retained 3.6–41% of the added Cl, and there were also significant positive relationships between soil organic matter (SOM) and Cl⁻ (McGuire and Judd 2020). The proposed mechanism for this retention is the formation of organic Cl⁻ compounds which can occur biotically or abiotically, but microbially derived organic Cl⁻ compounds were the most likely source (McGuire and Judd 2020). Most Na⁺, Mg²⁺, and Ca²⁺ retention results were broadly similar in this study across stormwater BMP types and salt concentrations (Figure 2). Stormwater ponds in Maryland yielded higher Cl⁻ concentrations in both the winter and summer months, indicating that such ponds are the source of NaCl rich-groundwater plumes, with groundwater Cl⁻ concentrations reaching up to 421 mg/L due to increased groundwater connectivity (Cooper et al., 2014; Snodgrass et al., 2017).

FIGURE 6

FIGURE 6. Winter storm event sampling conducted at Wetland #2 from 1/28/22 through 1/29/22. Sampling was conducted during a snowstorm where road salting occurred on the University of Maryland College Park campus. Base cation exchange is thought to drive the elemental mobilization seen after the peak Na⁺ concentration (2140 mg/L) was reached.

Though not studied directly by this research, retention time and the intensity and duration of road salt application each winter may also play a critical role in determining how long before stormwater BMPs exchange sites become completely saturated (Barbier et al., 2018; Burgis et al., 2020). Exchange site saturation was observed at Wetland #2 and nearly all sites exhibited diminishing percent cation retention at 10 g Cl/L incubations. Desorption of cations during the spring may take months to reach pre-roadsalt exposure levels. Retention ponds in France showed that 91% of the salt adsorbed during the winter was removed by March 1st, despite Ca²⁺ levels reaching 503.65 mg/L (Barbier et al., 2018). Bioswales and bioretention sites also showed similar trends, temporarily reducing effluent surface loads during a snow storm by 82% and 76%, but retaining little Na⁺ long-term (up to 200 mg/kg in the summer) (Burgis et al., 2020). As road salt applications are seasonal in temperate climates, freshwater (with low salinity) from spring and summer precipitation typically desorbs accumulated salt ions from stormwater BMPs. Cation retention followed by chemical cocktail mobilization may explain the complicated sink (Figure 2)/source (Figure 3) dynamics found in our study.

FSS impacts function of stormwater BMPs

Our results showed that different types of salt ions have the potential to affect patterns and processes in stormwater BMPs relevant to soil structure and hydrological and biogeochemical functions. Currently, watershed restoration strategies employ stormwater BMPs to slow and store urban runoff, enhance infiltration and hydrologic residence times, and boost biogeochemical functions related to contaminant retention and removal (Davis 2008; Koch et al., 2014; Maas et al., 2021). However, increased salinization can reduce infiltration capacity and the ability for urban runoff to percolate through stormwater BMPs (Behbahani et al., 2021). In addition, ion exchange sites in soils can become saturated with Na⁺ and other ions and shift stormwater BMPs from contaminant sinks to sources (Snodgrass et al., 2017; McGuire and Judd 2020). Finally, increased salinization can alter microbial and plant processes and influence rates of biogeochemical processes related to contaminant retention in stormwater BMPs (Kim and Koretsky 2013). Future research should consider incorporating monitoring of these chemical and biological processes. Below, we explore how salts can influence infiltration rates, ion exchange and saturation of exchange sites, and microbial and plant processes.

Stormwater BMPs appear to provide a complex combination of positive and negative effects for their associated watersheds (e.g., we found retention of cations but release of other elements). Peak discharge and nutrients are generally reduced, but cations, metals, and organic matter can be mobilized during road salting events (as observed in this study) (Figures 2, 3, 5; Tables 3, 4, 5) (Davis 2008; Koch et al., 2014). At high salt concentrations, metals can reach levels that are harmful to both freshwater biota and humans (Kondakis et al., 1989; Mahrosh et al., 2014). Accidental and designed wetlands may decrease peak salinity downstream but may also funnel surficial water contamination directly into groundwater aquifers (Palta et al., 2017; Maas et al., 2021). Stormwater BMPs offer more environmental benefits than cement culverts and buried streams, but further study must be conducted regarding risks associated with freshwater salinization (Kaushal et al., 2021, 2022a, b). If salt use continues or increases, the quantity of metals released may begin to decrease as colloids become depleted of metals with constant base cation exchange and flushing downstream (Fernandez et al., 2003). Evidence of exchangeable metal depletion may be present in the Wetland #2 site, one of the oldest sites in the study at ≥30 years old, which mobilized less Cu than any other site, especially during NaCl incubation (Figure 3). Further work should investigate the factors influencing cation exchange capacity in stormwater BMPs and elucidate the role of organic carbon vs. clays.

Our results suggest that FSS can alter organic matter in stormwater BMPs similar to other studies (Kaushal et al., 2022a; Kaushal et al., 2022b); this may have implications for changes in soil aggregate structure, erosion potential, and infiltration rates. Our study found that concentrations of DOC increased in response to initial stages of salinization, significantly from salinization with Na⁺, consistent with changes in solubility and destruction of soil aggregates due to Na⁺ dispersion and loss of cation bridging from Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ in sodic soils (Figure 3; Table 4) (Green et al., 2008a, c; Abolfazli and Strom 2022; Norrstrom and Bergstedt, 2020). In sodic or saline-sodic soils with exchangeable sodium percentages >15 and an exchange of Na⁺, replacing Ca²⁺ or Mg²⁺ soil aggregates break up, hydraulic conductivity decreases and colloid mobility increases. Changes in pH can also influence this process though it was not recorded in this study. Our results also showed some rapid declines in DOC concentrations at higher levels of salinization at Bioretention #1 and Wetland #1, before reaching a threshold (between 2.5 and 5 g Cl⁻/L) and once again increasing. This may indicate flocculation of soil particles at higher salinities (Figure 3) (Abolfazli and Strom 2022). At high concentrations ≥947 μS/cm flocculation is thought to occur due to a decrease in the thickness of the double layer. As the double layer shrinks, this allows for the repulsion force to be overcome by the attraction force and aggregates form (Abolfazli and Strom 2022). Loss of soil aggregates can lead to increased erosion in stormwater BMPs and mobilization of contaminants bound to sediments, similar to increased erosion in other salinized soils (Behbahani et al., 2021). Increased flocculation at higher levels of salinity can lead to clogging of soils and sediments in stormwater BMPs and reductions in infiltration capacity similar to other salinized soils (Abolfazli and Strom 2022). Much previous work in other salinized soils has shown that the amounts and types of salt ions can impact soil aggregate structure, hydraulic conductivity, and infiltration rates (Green et al., 2008a, c; Snodgrass et al., 2017; Abolfazli and Strom 2022).

The effectiveness of different stormwater BMPs to retain contaminants is also related to abiotic factors such as CEC of soils and sediments (Peinemann et al., 2005; Green SophieM. et al., 2008). Different stormwater BMPs have been shown to have CEC ranging from 2.9 meq/100 g soil to 25.91 meq/100 g soil (Davis et al., 2001; Behbahani et al., 2021). We observed significant differences in retention of Na⁺, Ca²⁺, and Mg²⁺ and trace metals in the different stormwater BMPs in this study, possibly due to differences in CEC across stormwater BMPs, landscape position, age and pollution history (Rieuwerts et al., 1998). In older stormwater BMPs receiving high levels of pollution like Pond #1, cation exchange sites may become occupied with metals such as Mn (Figures 2, 3), becoming more susceptible to mobilization of contaminants (Snodgrass et al., 2017; McGuire and Judd 2020). Stormwater BMPs may also show potential for retaining Na⁺ and other cations even into the summer as was seen in previous work by this research group (Galella et al., 2021) and others (Snodgrass et al., 2017; McGuire and Judd 2020). Stormwater BMPs saturated with Na⁺ may have significantly decreased capacity to serve as contaminant sinks in urban watersheds and landscapes. We observed that a) maximum salt ion retention usually occurred at the lowest concentrations (1 g Cl⁻/L), b) decreasing as Cl⁻ concentration increased, indicating that exchange sites were becoming exhausted as greater quantities of cations were added. Na⁺ had significantly higher retention than Ca²⁺ or Mg²⁺, likely due to cations in soil aggregates (Figure 2). Differences in retention thresholds among sites may have also been due to changes in organic matter content and quality of the sediments, or differences in CEC of the soils. These variables should be included in future research on this topic.

FSS can influence the function of stormwater BMPs by altering biogeochemical processes, like encouraging the growth of fungal and microbial mats which may in turn mobilize Fe and Mn into the environment (though only Mn mobilization was observed in this study) (Kim and Koretsky 2013). Previous work suggests that microbial activity can be influenced by factors influenced by FSS. For example, microbial biomass and activity were positively correlated with organic carbon, total nitrogen, pH, moisture content, total petroleum hydrocarbons, and watershed area ratio (a ratio of the area draining into the feature to the area of the stormwater BMP itself) (Deeb et al., 2018). We observed a statistically significant increase in TDN with increased salt concentrations for all salts tested (NaCl, CaCl₂, and MgCl₂). The ions that produced the largest increases in TDN were Mg²⁺ and Na⁺. Na⁺ mobilized concentrations up to 17 mg/L likely because it is monovalent and can more easily mobilize NH₄⁺. Duckworth & Cresser (1991) noted that high Na⁺ inputs flush ammonium ions from their exchange sites, also reducing retention from atmospheric sources (Duckworth and Cresser 1991). Elevated ammonium concentrations in waterways affected by FSS have also been attributed to a combination of dissimlatory nitrate reduction to ammonium (DNRA) and ammonification with associated diminished nitrification (Inamdar et al., 2022). Changes in pH due to displacement of H⁺ by Na⁺ and alkalinization over time have also been observed (Green et al., 2008a, b, c). Nitrification and denitrification can be enhanced at slightly elevated pH and N cycles may be altered based on availability of Ca²⁺ and calcareous soils (Green et al., 2008a, b, c). Increased salinization has the potential influence the N cycle of stormwater BMPs and further research needs to look at this in more depth at the watershed scale (Collins et al., 2010; Passeport et al., 2013).

Thresholds for aquatic life and formation of chemical cocktails in stormwater BMPs

In this study, we measured specific conductance in stormwater management features >8000 uS/cm, well above EPA thresholds of 230 uS/cm for aquatic life in the Mid-Appalachian region (EPA 2011). Targeted sampling conducted during a winter storm at Wetland #2 revealed extremely high concentrations of Na⁺, up to 2140 mg/L (Figure 6) triggering mobilization of major and trace elements similar to our laboratory incubation experiments. As was expected in stormwater BMPs, the salinity levels in Wetland #2 were higher than typically recorded in urban streams in the area (Galella et al., 2021; Kaushal et al., 2022a, b). The levels of salinization used in our study were within ecologically relevant ranges reported for other systems. Salt concentrations as low as 217–445 mg Cl⁻/L have caused shifts in species composition, particularly plankton and benthic organisms, towards more salt tolerant species, which may in turn lead to eutrophication due to a combination of reduced grazing pressure from zooplankton and a release of nutrients, particularly phosphorus from lake sediments (Hintz and Relyea 2019). Future salt incubation studies should consider incorporating monitoring of aquatic flora and fauna into their design.

Our results also showed increasing trends of major and trace elements with increasing salt concentrations contributing to the formation of chemical cocktails. Chemical cocktails of salt ions, metals, and nutrients also increased in concentration with increasing salinization. Mobilization of major and trace elements was not uniform across the different salts used in incubations. PCA and ANOVA results showed significant co-mobilization of Cu and NaCl (Figures 4, 7). At every concentration tested, NaCl incubations mobilized Cu at concentrations more than an order of magnitude greater than MgCl₂ and CaCl₂ (Figure 7). For example, averaged results for samples incubated with 10 g/L Cl mobilized 0.11 mg/L of Cu for CaCl₂ incubations, 0.17 mg/L Cu for MgCl₂ incubations and 4.21 mg/L Cu for NaCl incubations. Elevated Cu concentrations are likely due to Na⁺ dispersion of organic matter rich colloids. Cu is dispersed from sediment particle layers into suspension when Na⁺ concentrations are elevated (Kaushal et al., 2020; Kinsman-Costello et al., 2022). Sr²⁺ also showed significant co-mobilization with CaCl, mobilizing more than double the concentration compared to the other salts studied. This is likely due to the shared charges of Ca²⁺ and Sr²⁺.

FIGURE 7

FIGURE 7. Comparison of Cu mobilized by different salt treatments. NaCl treatments mobilized Cu at a rate more than an order of magnitude higher than CaCl₂ or MgCl₂. The EPA’s Cu limit for drinking water is shown by the yellow line at 1.3 mg/L (US EPA 2015c, b).

Although stormwater BMPs may not contain as many species as natural ecosystems, they can be important urban habitats (Snodgrass et al., 2008; Van Meter et al., 2011). Increased major ion concentrations can directly cause detrimental effects on freshwater biota (Clements and Kotalik 2016; Hintz and Relyea 2019). Insects, when exposed to concentrations of aqueous NaHCO₃, MgSO₄, and NaCl ranging from 60 to 300 μS/cm, had lower metabolic rates and abundance than control populations (Clements and Kotalik 2016). With local specific conductance levels surpassing 1,000 μS/cm nearly every winter in urban streams surrounding the study site, it is likely that salinity alone is negatively affecting aquatic food webs. Certain species of zooplankton (Daphnia pulex) can develop cross-tolerance to different deicers (Hintz et al., 2019). For example, those species tolerant of height concentrations of NaCl were also tolerant of elevated MgCl₂ and CaCl₂ (Hintz et al., 2019). However, salt-tolerant species reproduced more slowly than less tolerant species (Hintz et al., 2019). Rainbow trout fry showed no negative impacts when exposed to MgCl₂ up to 3000 mg/L, but did show reduced growth when exposed to NaCl at 3000 mg Cl⁻/L and CaCl₂ at 860 mg Cl⁻/L (Hintz and Relyea 2017). Atlantic salmon embryos exhibited larval deformities when exposed to NaCl concentrations ≥5000 mg/L combined with Cu at (10 μg Cu/L) (Mahrosh et al., 2014). These deformities were not present when embryos were exposed to solely NaCl concentrations ≥5000 mg/L although there was increased egg mortality (Mahrosh et al., 2014). The synergistic detrimental effects of NaCl and Cu when combined illustrate the importance of studying chemical cocktails as a whole instead of focusing on individual elements one at a time. Incubations for this study contained up to 16,500 mg/L of added NaCl and 15,700 mg/L of added CaCl₂, chosen to be within a realistic range of salinities expected at the stormwater BMPs selected (Table 2), far exceeding the thresholds established for aquatic ecosystem harm (Hintz and Relyea 2017). More work needs to investigate the effects of salinization on contaminant mobilization and toxicity to aquatic life.

Impacts of alternative road salt ions compared with NaCl

A key component of the present study was to compare the impacts of different common road salt ions on retention and release of multiple elements. We found significant differences in retention and release of chemical cocktails, but it is important to place these results within context when considering management implications. The effectiveness of different types of salt ions as deicers is dependent on temperature. For example, NaCl is capable of melting snow and ice to as low as -9.4°C, but MgCl₂ and CaCl₂ melt snow and ice to -20.6 °C and -31.7°C, respectively (Kissner 2012a, b; Diamond Crystal 2017). CaCl₂ was found to be the most effective deicer to use on snow and ice, followed by MgCl₂ (Kołodziejczyk and Ćwiąkała 2009). Our results show that site type usually had less of an effect than salt concentration and salt type on the mobilization of metals, nutrients, and carbon (Tables 3, 4, and 5). Regardless of stormwater BMP, the amount and type of road salt applied is the most significant factor controlling major and trace element mobilization (Table 3 and Figure 3). Na⁺, being monovalent, often mobilizes major and trace elements differently from divalent Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ (Table 4). If CaCl₂ is used as a deicer instead of NaCl, it may be possible to apply less total road salt and still achieve road safety due to CaCl₂’s lower melting temperature and greater efficacy (Kołodziejczyk and Ćwiąkała 2009). Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ also contribute to water hardness, often reducing the toxicity of certain metals (Ebrahimpour et al., 2010). Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺ may also have less detrimental effects on soil aggregate stability than Na⁺ (Green et al., 2008a, c). Depending on the contaminant of concern (e.g. Cu) and environmental issues (soil erosion), the use of alternative deicers other than NaCl could reduce the overall quantity of salt used while still maintaining safe roadway travel. Currently cost is a major obstacle restricting the use of alternative salts, as NaCl is the least expensive deicer option in the United States (Tiwari and Rachlin 2018).

Scientific limitations of study and path for future research

Though every effort was made to perform a robust assessment of the effects of FSS on chemical cocktail mobilization, some limitations still exist. Though replicate stormwater BMPs were sampled they were all within a geographically limited area which could be expanded in future studies. Mobilization of nitrogen and possible redox reactions are often associated with changes in the pH of water and sediment. pH data would have been a useful additional data source which should be considered for future similar studies. The organic matter content of sediment samples collected should also be explored in future studies as it may help better define the differences in retention and release observed at different stormwater BMPs. A more in-depth analysis of sediment particle size makeup would also help better describe retention and release mechanisms. Analysis of biological communities in stormwater BMPs before and after road salting events would also be helpful to determine what the impacts of FSS are on both flora and fauna.

Conclusion

Salt concentration, salt type, and, to a lesser extent, site type determines the composition and concentrations of chemical cocktails released from stormwater BMPs. Increasing the concentration of NaCl, CaCl₂, or MgCl₂ in stormwater BMP water and sediment samples mobilizes chemical cocktails or major and trace elements in a linear fashion for certain elements (Cu, K, and Sr²⁺) (Figure 3). Different salts show increased mobilization, with NaCl mobilizing Cu at concentrations more than an order of magnitude more than CaCl₂, or MgCl₂, and CaCl₂ preferentially mobilized Sr²⁺. Concentrations of mobilized elements exceeded water quality standards for certain metals such as Cu and Mn (US EPA 2015a, b). Results showed that the amounts of salt ions had significant effects on mobilization of a wide variety of contaminants including nutrients, other salt ions, and metals. The amounts of road salts applied to impervious surfaces during winter months and the amounts of salt loadings from other potential sources is not closely tracked. More work on calibrating and tracking road salt application rates is necessary to reduce risk from excess Na⁺, Mn, and Cu.

Our research also suggests that there are important interactions between salt ions and mobilization of carbon, nitrogen, and metals from stormwater BMPs. Though the dataset is incomplete due to an instrument malfunction, positive relationships were observed between NaCl, CaCl₂, MgCl₂ and DOC and TN at bioswale sites (Supplementary Figure S4). Inorganic carbon has mixed results with both increasing and decreasing trends observed across bioswale, bioretention, and wetland sites (Supplementary Figure S4). Strategic efforts to minimize biogeochemical interactions that mobilize contaminants of concern (below concentration thresholds determined from this study) can be used to better inform goals for meeting total maximum daily loads (TMDLs). Our results also showed that the types of salt ions impacted contaminant mobilization potentials. This information may be used to guide selection of alternative deicers based on biogeochemical interactions and potential water quality impacts. Our results also showed that different stormwater BMPs can retain significant amounts of salts and that salt type and site type influence their retention potential (Figure 3). The extremely saline environments present in stormwater BMPs that we observed after road salting (up to 2140 mg/L Na⁺) elevate the risk of formation of groundwater chemical cocktail plumes, especially because many stormwater BMPs both increase groundwater connectivity and generate unique chemical cocktails. For example, elevated Cl⁻ from chemical cocktail plumes may still be detectable 15 km away from the stormwater BMP that generated them (Snodgrass et al., 2017). Further research will be needed to determine if other mobilized elements may be transported and over what distances. Overall, our results suggest that reducing the level of salt ions significantly reduces the mobilization of contaminants from sediments to streams. Our results also clearly show that selecting different types of salt ions can have significantly different effects on mobilizing contaminants. The amounts and types of salt ions need to be considered explicitly in watershed management and restoration strategies to more effectively reduce risk to human health and the environment.

Our results highlight the complexity of stormwater BMPs and their roles in contaminant retention and release under varying environmental conditions. Incubation results and field measurements suggest that the stormwater BMPs studied behaved as contaminant sources rather than sinks during road salting events, similar to the urban streams studied in Galella et al. (2021). The environmental benefits of nutrient storage and peak storm discharge reduction offered by stormwater BMPs contrasts with the unintended consequences of chemical cocktail mobilization after road salting (Davis 2008; Koch et al., 2014). This is further complicated by the potential of stormwater BMPs to generate groundwater chemical cocktail plumes (Snodgrass et al., 2017). Though NaCl is often the most cost-effective deicer available, the use of brines, MgCl₂ and CaCl₂ should be considered as an alternative, especially in environmentally fragile areas or where fisheries are affected by Cu pollution. Further research on alternative deicers is needed, as their full effect on the food web, particularly on zooplankton is still not fully known (Hintz et al., 2022).

Data availability statement

The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors, without undue reservation.

Author contributions

JG - Conducted the vast majority of field and lab work for this study, was also the lead author for the manuscript. SK - Advised JG throughout field and lab work and provided extensive editorial assistance with manuscript. PM - Advised JG throughout field and lab work and provided extensive editorial assistance with manuscript. CM - Provided help with sample collection and some lab work. Also assisted in editing of manuscript. RUS - Provided help with lab work. Also assisted in editing of manuscript. ROS - Provided assistance with lab and field work.

Funding

This work was supported by Chesapeake Bay Trust Restoration Research grant 16918 and its funding partners, Maryland Sea Grant SA75281870W, Washington Metropolitan Council of Governments contract # 21-001, National Science Foundation Growing Convergence Research 2021089, and the United States Environmental Protection Agency.

Acknowledgments

The information in this document has been subjected to United States Environmental Protection Agency (Agency) peer and administrative review, and it has been approved for publication as an Agency document. The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views or policies of the Agency. Any mention of trade names, products, or services does not imply an endorsement by the United States Government or the Agency. Special thanks to Lewis Linker (EPA), Laura Sammon (MATLAB) for their substantial contributions and Sydney Weiss (EPA) Doug Beak (EPA) and Patti Meeks (EPA) for their edits.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Publisher’s note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Supplementary material

The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenvs.2023.1020914/full#supplementary-material

Footnotes

¹In this paper, we indicate charges for ions with one oxidation state, but do not indicate charge for elements with multiple oxidation states.

References

Abolfazli, E., and Strom, K. (2022). Deicing road salts may contribute to impairment of streambeds through alterations to sedimentation processes. ACS Est. Water 2, 148–155. doi:10.1021/acsestwater.1c00300